Wishlist by Square vs Wishlist Geniefor Shopify (2026)
In 2026, merchants choosing between Wishlist by Square and Wishlist Genie for their Shopify stores are presented with significantly different options. Wishlist by Square, backed by Square, offers a seemingly established solution, evidenced by a perfect 5-star rating and 11 reviews. Its focus is on simplicity and ease of use, working 'out of the box' and automatically tracking wishlist activity without requiring customer accounts. This positions it for merchants prioritizing a frictionless experience and actionable insights into customer buying intent. Conversely, Wishlist Genie is a newcomer, currently without any ratings or reviews, but it aims to enhance the customer experience through personalized product tracking and wishlisting, appealing to merchants focused on building long-term customer loyalty with an account-based system and easy setup.
At a Glance
Wishlist by Square
11 reviews
Wishlist Genie
0 reviews
Detailed Overview
Wishlist by Square
Boost sales with Wishlist features - let shoppers save favorites in a personal wish list
Key Features
- Let shoppers save products for later with a one-click Wishlist button
- Works without customer accounts — saves and tracks products automatically
- Customers manage saved items and add to cart from the Wishlist page
- Customize text, colors, icons, and placement to match your brand store
- Track saved products, Wishlist value, and shopper interest with insights
Wishlist Genie
Enhance customer experience by allowing personalized product tracking and easy wishlisting
Key Features
- Customers can effortlessly save products to return to later
- Easily move saved items to the cart when ready to purchase
- Customers can view, update, or remove saved products at any time
- Installs quickly with your Shopify theme, up and running in under 5 minutes
- Works for both guest shoppers and registered accounts
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 0/5 |
Rating Wishlist by Square5/5 Wishlist Genie0/5 | ||
| Reviews | 11 | 0 |
Reviews Wishlist by Square11 Wishlist Genie0 | ||
| Account Requirement | No Account Required (automatic tracking) | Works for Guest and Registered Accounts |
Account Requirement Wishlist by SquareNo Account Required (automatic tracking) Wishlist GenieWorks for Guest and Registered Accounts | ||
| Insight Tracking | Detailed insights on saved products, wishlist value, and shopper interest | Not explicitly mentioned |
Insight Tracking Wishlist by SquareDetailed insights on saved products, wishlist value, and shopper interest Wishlist GenieNot explicitly mentioned | ||
| Customization | Flexible design settings (text, colors, icons, placement), 15 languages | Theme integration, quick setup (under 5 minutes) |
Customization Wishlist by SquareFlexible design settings (text, colors, icons, placement), 15 languages Wishlist GenieTheme integration, quick setup (under 5 minutes) | ||
| Setup Complexity | Out-of-the-box functionality | Installs quickly with Shopify theme |
Setup Complexity Wishlist by SquareOut-of-the-box functionality Wishlist GenieInstalls quickly with Shopify theme | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants wanting immediate insights without customer account friction | Merchants focused on personalized experience with account support |
Target Audience Wishlist by SquareMerchants wanting immediate insights without customer account friction Wishlist GenieMerchants focused on personalized experience with account support | ||
Our Verdict
Wishlist by Square is the safer bet for merchants prioritizing ease of use, instant setup, and data-driven insights without the need for customer accounts. The app's existing positive reviews offer confidence in its functionality. It is especially suitable for merchants who want to quickly understand which products are most popular among their customers. Wishlist Genie, although promising, lacks the social proof of reviews and ratings. It is better suited for merchants willing to take a risk on a newer app, particularly if they value the flexibility of offering wishlist functionality to both guest and registered customers, and are highly focused on customer accounts.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps claim easy setup. Wishlist by Square works 'out of the box,' suggesting a very simple configuration. Wishlist Genie promises a quick installation in under 5 minutes, indicating a straightforward process as well. However, the actual difference may depend on the complexity of the store's theme.
Which app offers better insights into customer behavior?
Wishlist by Square explicitly mentions tracking saved products, wishlist value, and shopper interest, offering merchants data-driven insights. Wishlist Genie does not explicitly mention providing such insights.
Which app is more customizable?
Wishlist by Square boasts flexible design settings, including text, colors, icons, and placement options, along with support for 15 languages. Wishlist Genie's customization options are not detailed in the description, suggesting fewer customization options.
Does either app require customers to create an account to use the wishlist?
Wishlist by Square works without customer accounts, saving and tracking products automatically. Wishlist Genie is compatible with both guest shoppers and registered accounts.
Which app has more social proof in the form of ratings and reviews?
Wishlist by Square has a 5/5 rating based on 11 reviews. Wishlist Genie has a 0/5 rating with no reviews.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store