Best Alternatives to Wishlist by Squarefor Shopify (2026)

Shopney is a strong choice if you're looking to create a mobile app for your Shopify store. While it doesn't directly replace the wishlist functionality, the app builder focuses on enhancing the overall shopping experience on mobile, which could indirectly improve sales.

Recurpay is designed for subscription-based businesses. It won't replace your wishlist functionality, but it's ideal if you want to offer subscriptions and manage recurring payments with features like customer self-service and customizable subscription widgets.

Loyoly offers a unique loyalty program by rewarding customers for User-Generated Content (UGC), reviews, and social engagement. If you want a loyalty program that is different than the standard points and referral setup, you could consider this alternative. While not directly replacing wishlist, can improve customer engagement.

GoodAPI allows you to integrate sustainability initiatives, like planting trees and removing ocean plastic, into your store. While not a wishlist app, it can enhance customer loyalty by appealing to eco-conscious consumers. It can be an addon to a wishlist app.

Swish directly competes with Wishlist by Square, offering a feature-rich wishlist solution with free setup and customization. It stands out with its advanced analytics, integrations with Klaviyo, GA4, and Meta, and personalized automated notifications to drive conversion.

Froonze combines both a Loyalty Program and Wishlist in one app. Consider this if you're looking for a consolidated solution that handles both functionalities within a unified customer account, along with features like email alerts for price drops and low stock on wishlisted items.

Wishify is a straightforward wishlist app that focuses on increasing sales and conversion through features like social sharing and automated email reminders. It is ideal if you specifically want features to encourage customers to share their Wishlist and get reminders to purchase.

E! focuses on customer retention and engagement through loyalty programs, referrals, and VIP tiers. You might consider this alternative if you want to integrate wishlist functionality with a broader loyalty system, offering rewards for adding items to wishlists or purchasing from them.

Like E!, BLOY focuses on building a loyalty program to drive customer retention. If your goal is to combine wishlist functionality with a loyalty program that rewards customer actions and offers VIP tiers, BLOY could be a good option.

Love Loyalty Program & Rewards offers a loyalty program with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referrals, along with POS support and membership features. It's a good choice if you're looking to integrate wishlist data with a broader loyalty strategy and want support for both online and physical stores.