Shipday : Delivery + Pickup vs Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)for Shopify (2026)
Shipday : Delivery + Pickup and Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) both target Shopify merchants seeking to enhance their local fulfillment options with store pickup and delivery features. However, they differ significantly in user perception and functionality. Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) boasts a stellar 5-star rating based on a substantial 350 reviews, suggesting high user satisfaction. It focuses on flexible scheduling, multi-location management, and granular control over pickup and delivery rules, with a strong emphasis on restaurants. Shipday : Delivery + Pickup, on the other hand, has a very low rating of 1.8/5 with only 7 reviews. It positions itself as an AI-powered solution and emphasizes automated delivery management through integrated third-party delivery services like Uber and DoorDash, along with live tracking and SMS notifications, appealing to a broader range of businesses beyond restaurants, including grocers, florists, and bakeries.
At a Glance
Shipday : Delivery + Pickup
7 reviews
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)
350 reviews
Detailed Overview
Shipday : Delivery + Pickup
AI powered store pick up and local delivery management system
Key Features
- Store pick up: Allow customers to select pickup location, date, and time.
- Scheduled Delivery: Let customers choose specific delivery dates/times
- Live Delivery Tracking on Google Maps
- ETA Sharing with SMS Notifications to Customers
- Instant Access to DoorDash and Uber for Delivery (US & Canada)
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)
Boost sales with flexible delivery and local order pickup scheduling that improves local fulfillment
Key Features
- Set minimum pickup days, preparation time, blackout specific days
- Easily organize local pickup or local delivery orders with the help of tags
- Limit number of local pickup orders per time slot or per day
- Offer delivery each day in specific zip code areas. Offer location surcharge.
- Disable shipping by making a specific collection mandatory for pickup.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 1.8/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Shipday : Delivery + Pickup1.8/5 Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 7 | 350 |
Reviews Shipday : Delivery + Pickup7 Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)350 | ||
| Delivery Management | Integrates with 3rd party delivery services (Uber, DoorDash) | Focuses on scheduling and in-house fulfillment management |
Delivery Management Shipday : Delivery + PickupIntegrates with 3rd party delivery services (Uber, DoorDash) Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Focuses on scheduling and in-house fulfillment management | ||
| Scheduling Flexibility | Offers scheduled delivery with date/time picker | Highly flexible, setting minimum days, prep time, blackout dates, zip code areas, and location surcharges |
Scheduling Flexibility Shipday : Delivery + PickupOffers scheduled delivery with date/time picker Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Highly flexible, setting minimum days, prep time, blackout dates, zip code areas, and location surcharges | ||
| Order Limits | Not specified | Limits orders per time slot or per day |
Order Limits Shipday : Delivery + PickupNot specified Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Limits orders per time slot or per day | ||
| Target Audience | Restaurants, meal-prep, bakeries, florists, grocers | Primarily restaurants |
Target Audience Shipday : Delivery + PickupRestaurants, meal-prep, bakeries, florists, grocers Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Primarily restaurants | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | Potentially complex due to AI and 3rd party integration; low rating raises concerns. | Implied to be user-friendly due to high rating and detailed scheduling options. |
Ease of Use (Implied) Shipday : Delivery + PickupPotentially complex due to AI and 3rd party integration; low rating raises concerns. Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Implied to be user-friendly due to high rating and detailed scheduling options. | ||
| Value Proposition | Automated delivery management and 3rd party integration | Flexible scheduling and control over local fulfillment |
Value Proposition Shipday : Delivery + PickupAutomated delivery management and 3rd party integration Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)Flexible scheduling and control over local fulfillment | ||
Our Verdict
Given the significant difference in ratings and the number of reviews, Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) appears to be the more reliable choice for merchants seeking a robust and user-friendly solution for managing local pickup and delivery, particularly if their primary need is flexible scheduling and in-house management. It seems especially well-suited for restaurants. Shipday : Delivery + Pickup might be considered by merchants who highly value automated delivery management and integration with third-party delivery services, but the low rating and limited reviews suggest proceeding with caution and thoroughly investigating its current functionality and support quality before committing. Merchants should closely scrutinize the reasons behind the low rating, and determine if the issues have been resolved since the reviews were written.
Common Questions
Which app is better for restaurants?
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) seems to be a more reliable and well-regarded option for restaurants due to its higher rating, larger number of reviews, and specific features tailored to restaurant needs such as setting preparation times.
Which app offers integration with third-party delivery services?
Shipday : Delivery + Pickup integrates with third-party delivery services like Uber, DoorDash, Roadie, and Stuart.
Which app allows for more granular control over scheduling?
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) provides more granular control over scheduling, allowing merchants to set minimum pickup days, preparation time, blackout specific days, limit orders per time slot or per day, and offer location surcharges.
Which app has a better user rating?
Store Pickup + Delivery (CR) has a significantly better user rating of 5/5 compared to Shipday : Delivery + Pickup's rating of 1.8/5.
Is Shipday : Delivery + Pickup easier to get started with?
While Shipday advertises AI powered features, the reviews and low rating suggest it may not be the easiest to implement. Store Pickup + Delivery (CR)'s flexibility might require setup, but the higher ratings suggest ease of use. Testing both apps is recommended.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store