Selling Point vs Shopfor Shopify (2026)
Selling Point and Shop are Shopify apps targeting vastly different needs. Selling Point focuses on a niche but crucial function: migrating gift card and store credit data from other platforms to Shopify. Its core value proposition is saving merchants time and money by streamlining the often-manual or custom-developed process of migrating gift card balances. Shop, on the other hand, aims to expand a merchant's reach by integrating with the Shop marketplace, offering access to millions of high-intent shoppers and features designed to boost conversion rates, such as Shop Pay and push notifications for abandoned carts. Selling Point caters to merchants migrating from other e-commerce platforms or POS systems who have a significant outstanding balance of gift cards or store credits. Shop, however, is useful to any Shopify merchant aiming to increase visibility and sales by tapping into a large, pre-verified customer base. The apps have an overlap in that they both aim to increase sales for the merchant, however, Selling Point focuses on retaining existing customers, while Shop is focused on attracting new ones. The risk of adopting Selling Point is the niche functionality might become irrelevant or outdated if Shopify drastically changes its gift card functionality. The risk of adopting Shop is that the potential customer base on the Shop platform might not be as valuable as that on other platforms.
At a Glance
Selling Point
45 reviews
Shop
3,632 reviews
Detailed Overview
Selling Point
Easily migrate or import Gift Cards or Store Credits from any POS system or website into your store
Key Features
- Migrate your existing Gift Cards from any platform into Shopify Gift Cards.
- Import store credit from another system into a native Store Credit in bulk.
- Ability to import physical gift cards as virtual gift cards in bulk.
- Transform offline Gift Cards into virtual native Gift Cards/Store Credits.
- Bulk generate & auto send out Gift Cards for your marketing promotions.
Shop
Reach millions of high-intent shoppers on Shop
Key Features
- Bring your brand to life with video, custom headers, and enhanced branding
- Add collections, subscriptions, and offers—just like your online store
- Let customers check out right on Shop or send them to your online store
- Increase conversions with Shop Pay and frictionless 1-tap checkout
- Reduce abandoned carts with automatic push notifications
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.8/5 |
Rating Selling Point5/5 Shop4.8/5 | ||
| Reviews | 45 | 3632 |
Reviews Selling Point45 Shop3632 | ||
| Core Function | Gift Card/Store Credit Migration | Sales Channel on Shop Marketplace |
Core Function Selling PointGift Card/Store Credit Migration ShopSales Channel on Shop Marketplace | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants migrating from other platforms with existing gift card balances. | All Shopify merchants seeking increased visibility and sales. |
Target Merchant Selling PointMerchants migrating from other platforms with existing gift card balances. ShopAll Shopify merchants seeking increased visibility and sales. | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially technical depending on data format from source system. | Generally easy, integrates directly with existing Shopify store. |
Ease of Use Selling PointPotentially technical depending on data format from source system. ShopGenerally easy, integrates directly with existing Shopify store. | ||
| Value Proposition | Saves time and money on gift card migration, prevents loss of customer value. | Increases sales by tapping into a large, pre-verified customer base. |
Value Proposition Selling PointSaves time and money on gift card migration, prevents loss of customer value. ShopIncreases sales by tapping into a large, pre-verified customer base. | ||
| Primary Goal | Transition existing customer credit | Attract new customers |
Primary Goal Selling PointTransition existing customer credit ShopAttract new customers | ||
| Payment structure | Likely app payment | No marketplace fees to sell on Shop |
Payment structure Selling PointLikely app payment ShopNo marketplace fees to sell on Shop | ||
Our Verdict
If you're migrating to Shopify from another platform and have a substantial number of outstanding gift cards or store credits, Selling Point is almost essential. It directly addresses a common pain point during platform transitions and can prevent significant financial losses. However, the low number of reviews suggests a higher degree of risk due to lack of community validation. Conversely, if your primary goal is to grow your customer base and increase sales, Shop is the clear choice. Its integration with the Shop marketplace provides access to a vast audience and features designed to optimize conversions. While Selling Point solves a specific problem, Shop offers broader sales and marketing benefits for most Shopify merchants.
Common Questions
Is Selling Point a good option if I'm starting a new Shopify store?
Not likely. Selling Point is designed for *migrating* gift card data. If you don't have an existing gift card balance to transfer, it won't be useful.
Does Shop charge any fees for selling on the platform?
The description states that you pay no marketplace fees to sell on Shop.
Can I use both Selling Point and Shop simultaneously?
Yes, they address completely different aspects of running a Shopify store. Selling Point focuses on migration, while Shop focuses on sales and marketing.
How difficult is it to migrate gift card data with Selling Point?
The description states that it aims to make the process easy, enabling merchants to migrate in minutes, but the process likely depends on the format of the data from your previous platform.
What kind of stores benefit the most from Shop?
Shop is designed to benefit any Shopify store looking to increase visibility and sales by accessing the Shop marketplace. However, stores with visually appealing products and strong branding might see the greatest impact.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store