Open SignIn - Social Login and OTP Login with Phone offer distinct approaches to streamlining customer account creation and login processes on Shopify stores in 2026. Open SignIn focuses on leveraging existing social media accounts for quick and easy sign-ups, appealing to customers who prefer to avoid creating new passwords and filling out lengthy registration forms. It positions itself as offering the widest range of social login providers, including less common platforms like VK and Sina Weibo. The core strength of Open SignIn lies in its convenience for users already actively engaged on various social media platforms, potentially boosting registration rates and customer retention through a frictionless login experience. It's designed for ease of use with a single-click installation. In contrast, OTP Login with Phone prioritizes enhanced security and a passwordless experience through one-time passcodes sent via SMS or email. This app caters to security-conscious merchants and customers who prefer not to rely on social media accounts or remember multiple passwords. Its strength lies in providing a modern, secure, and convenient login method that integrates directly with mobile devices and email, increasing trust and potentially reducing cart abandonment due to login friction. The app allows for a greater degree of customization and control over the login experience, including setting OTP expiry times and managing account field updates. OTP Login aims at a smoother flow from landing to checkout.
25 reviews
39 reviews
Increase signups as well as ease signin using Social Login (Facebook / Google / Twitter etc.)
Enable fast, secure OTP login with phone number and email for a smooth store login experience.
| Rating | 4.1/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Open SignIn ‑ Social Login4.1/5 OTP Login with Phone5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 25 | 39 |
Reviews Open SignIn ‑ Social Login25 OTP Login with Phone39 | ||
| Login Method | Social Login (Facebook, Google, etc.) | OTP via Phone/Email |
Login Method Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginSocial Login (Facebook, Google, etc.) OTP Login with PhoneOTP via Phone/Email | ||
| Security Focus | Convenience-focused | Security and Passwordless Login |
Security Focus Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginConvenience-focused OTP Login with PhoneSecurity and Passwordless Login | ||
| Customization | UI Customization | OTP Settings, Account Fields, Rule-Based Controls |
Customization Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginUI Customization OTP Login with PhoneOTP Settings, Account Fields, Rule-Based Controls | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses targeting social media users, Shopify Plus stores | Businesses prioritizing security and modern login experiences |
Target Merchant Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginBusinesses targeting social media users, Shopify Plus stores OTP Login with PhoneBusinesses prioritizing security and modern login experiences | ||
| Ease of Use | Single-click installation | Theme Compatibility (Free & Paid) |
Ease of Use Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginSingle-click installation OTP Login with PhoneTheme Compatibility (Free & Paid) | ||
| Provider Support | Extensive social login platforms | SMS providers (MSG91, Firebase) |
Provider Support Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginExtensive social login platforms OTP Login with PhoneSMS providers (MSG91, Firebase) | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased sign-ups, easy sign-in | Fast, secure login, smoother checkout |
Value Proposition Open SignIn ‑ Social LoginIncreased sign-ups, easy sign-in OTP Login with PhoneFast, secure login, smoother checkout | ||
For merchants seeking to capitalize on social media trends and simplify registration for existing social media users, Open SignIn - Social Login provides a quick and easy solution. Its broad range of supported platforms makes it a versatile choice, especially for Shopify Plus stores using multipass. However, the relatively low rating and limited review count compared to its competitor suggest that user satisfaction might be a point to investigate further.
On the other hand, OTP Login with Phone is the superior choice for businesses prioritizing robust security and a modern passwordless login experience. The higher rating and greater number of reviews indicate stronger user satisfaction. Its integration with SMS providers and checkout buttons makes it ideal for stores aiming to streamline the purchasing process while maintaining a high level of security and trust. Ultimately, the decision hinges on whether convenience or security is the higher priority for the merchant and their target audience.
Open SignIn claims single-click installation, suggesting potentially faster initial setup than OTP Login with Phone, although the integration points of OTP Login with Phone might be more valuable in the long run.
Open SignIn's support for platforms like VK and Sina Weibo makes it potentially more appealing to markets where those platforms are popular. OTP Login with Phone's global applicability depends on SMS provider reach but is likely wider than Open SignIn's offering if configured correctly.
Neither app explicitly mentions Shopify Flow integration in their description or key features. Further research or direct contact with the app developers would be necessary to confirm compatibility.
OTP Login with Phone's OTP on Checkout feature is specifically designed to reduce cart abandonment by streamlining the signup/login process during checkout, reducing friction. Open SignIn reduces friction earlier in the process, at account creation.
OTP Login with Phone seems to offer more granular customization options related to OTP settings, account fields, and login rules, providing greater control over the user experience than Open SignIn's UI customization.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store