MyDesigns: Print on Demand vs Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandfor Shopify (2026)
MyDesigns: Print on Demand and Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand are both sourcing options on Shopify, but they cater to distinctly different niches. MyDesigns focuses on enabling merchants to create, publish, sell, and fulfill general print-on-demand products at scale, providing tools like a premium mockup generator and bulk publishing. Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand, on the other hand, concentrates on the cosmetics industry, facilitating the creation and sale of cosmetics on demand. Both apps aim to simplify the product sourcing and fulfillment process, but their target product types are radically different, meaning a merchant should choose based primarily on their product niche. While both offer sourcing capabilities, their target audiences diverge significantly. MyDesigns targets businesses looking to sell a wide array of customizable products via Print on Demand, focusing on tools to scale up production and manage a large product catalog efficiently. Selfnamed caters to cosmetic businesses that need to offer personalized cosmetics or create customized products on demand. This is especially useful for businesses aiming to offer unique formulations or private label opportunities. The rating discrepancy is also something to consider, although MyDesigns has fewer reviews which may skew the results.
At a Glance
MyDesigns: Print on Demand
29 reviews
Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand
36 reviews
Detailed Overview
MyDesigns: Print on Demand
MyDesigns makes it easy to create, publish, sell and fulfill Print on Demand products at scale.
Key Features
- Create, publish, and sell custom products
- Generate premium product mockups in bulk
- Fulfill personalized products effortlessly
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 4.3/5 |
Rating MyDesigns: Print on Demand5/5 Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand4.3/5 | ||
| Reviews | 29 | 36 |
Reviews MyDesigns: Print on Demand29 Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand36 | ||
| Product Focus | General Print on Demand | Cosmetics on Demand |
Product Focus MyDesigns: Print on DemandGeneral Print on Demand Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandCosmetics on Demand | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Premium Mockup Generator | Cosmetics Specific Customization (implied) |
Key Feature 1 MyDesigns: Print on DemandPremium Mockup Generator Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandCosmetics Specific Customization (implied) | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Bulk Publishing | Unknown (cosmetic formulation?) |
Key Feature 2 MyDesigns: Print on DemandBulk Publishing Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandUnknown (cosmetic formulation?) | ||
| Target Merchant | General POD businesses | Cosmetics brands and retailers |
Target Merchant MyDesigns: Print on DemandGeneral POD businesses Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandCosmetics brands and retailers | ||
| Ease of Use (relative) | Likely straightforward POD setup | Potentially complex due to formulations |
Ease of Use (relative) MyDesigns: Print on DemandLikely straightforward POD setup Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandPotentially complex due to formulations | ||
| Value Proposition | Scale and Efficiency | Customization and Niche Market Access |
Value Proposition MyDesigns: Print on DemandScale and Efficiency Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demandCustomization and Niche Market Access | ||
Our Verdict
The choice between MyDesigns: Print on Demand and Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand boils down to the product being sold. If a merchant is in the cosmetics business or plans to enter the cosmetics market with customized products, Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand is the obvious choice. It specializes in the intricacies of cosmetic formulations and demand.
However, for merchants selling any other type of product (clothing, mugs, phone cases, etc.) through a print-on-demand model, MyDesigns: Print on Demand is the better option. It offers tools specifically tailored to scaling a print-on-demand business, such as bulk publishing and a mockup generator. The higher rating, although based on fewer reviews, also suggests a potentially smoother user experience for print-on-demand merchants.
Common Questions
Which app is better for a clothing brand?
MyDesigns: Print on Demand is likely better for a clothing brand that offers print-on-demand apparel. Its general print-on-demand focus, mockup generator, and bulk publishing features make it ideal for managing a clothing line.
Does Selfnamed: Cosmetics on demand handle formulation compliance?
The description provided does not detail compliance handling. Merchants should investigate Selfnamed further to determine if it provides any help with cosmetic formulation regulations.
Can I use MyDesigns: Print on Demand to sell makeup bags?
Yes, you could likely use MyDesigns: Print on Demand to sell makeup bags, assuming they are printed with custom designs. MyDesigns focuses on printed products and doesn't specialize in the cosmetics themselves.
What are the key differences in scaling with these apps?
MyDesigns facilitates scaling through bulk publishing and efficient mockup generation, allowing rapid product releases. Scaling with Selfnamed would likely involve refining cosmetic formulations and optimizing personalized product offerings for a cosmetics-specific market.
Is one app easier to use than the other?
While both apps likely strive for usability, MyDesigns may be easier to adopt for merchants familiar with print-on-demand services. The complexities involved in cosmetic formulations might make Selfnamed slightly more challenging to configure initially, depending on its backend functionality.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store