Members Only Section vs XO Insert Codefor Shopify (2026)
Members Only Section and XO Insert Code are two Shopify apps that, despite sharing a category of 'Storefronts - Other', cater to very different needs and skill levels of Shopify merchants. Members Only Section focuses on providing a straightforward solution for creating gated content within a Shopify store, specifically by leveraging customer tags and customizable messages for logged-in and logged-out users. The primary value proposition is creating VIP sections or wholesale-only collections without requiring coding expertise, targetting merchants looking to segment their audience. In contrast, XO Insert Code targets merchants who need the ability to insert custom code (HTML, CSS, Javascript, Liquid) into their Shopify store. With a high rating and numerous reviews, it’s positioned as a user-friendly solution to add scripts, styles, or tracking pixels, appealing to merchants seeking deeper customization or integration with third-party services. It allows injecting code into specific pages, products, or collections, allowing targeted functionality beyond simple member-only access.
At a Glance
Members Only Section
0 reviews
XO Insert Code
91 reviews
Detailed Overview
Members Only Section
Adds a Members only section to any 2.0 Theme page or product template.
Key Features
- Works on any Shopify 2.0 theme without coding.
- Customer tag as trigger per section (can have different tags on each section)
- Custom message to logged in customers.
XO Insert Code
Anyone can insert code into their store.
Key Features
- Easy to insert and manage code in your shop.
- Add code to specific pages/products/collection.
- Add Google Analytics, Google tag manager, Facebook pixel... code.
- Add verify meta tag code.
- Insert any code or script, including HTML, CSS, Liquid and Javascript.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Members Only Section0/5 XO Insert Code5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 91 |
Reviews Members Only Section0 XO Insert Code91 | ||
| Main Function | Members-only content sections | Code insertion |
Main Function Members Only SectionMembers-only content sections XO Insert CodeCode insertion | ||
| Target User | Merchants segmenting audience via tags | Merchants needing custom code injection |
Target User Members Only SectionMerchants segmenting audience via tags XO Insert CodeMerchants needing custom code injection | ||
| Ease of Use | Simplified, requires no coding | Easy to use, but requires coding knowledge |
Ease of Use Members Only SectionSimplified, requires no coding XO Insert CodeEasy to use, but requires coding knowledge | ||
| Primary Value | Content restriction based on user tags | Flexibility to add custom functionality and integrations |
Primary Value Members Only SectionContent restriction based on user tags XO Insert CodeFlexibility to add custom functionality and integrations | ||
| Theme Compatibility | Shopify 2.0 Themes | No theme restrictions specified |
Theme Compatibility Members Only SectionShopify 2.0 Themes XO Insert CodeNo theme restrictions specified | ||
| Use Cases | VIP products, wholesale collections | Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, custom CSS |
Use Cases Members Only SectionVIP products, wholesale collections XO Insert CodeGoogle Analytics, Facebook Pixel, custom CSS | ||
Our Verdict
If a merchant's primary goal is to create member-only sections in their store and they lack coding expertise, Members Only Section seems like the only option even given its current rating of zero with no reviews, but the lack of social proof is a concern. Merchants should proceed with extreme caution due to the absence of reviews. If, however, the merchant needs a general-purpose code injection tool to implement tracking pixels, advanced customizations, or integrate third-party services, XO Insert Code is the clear winner with a strong rating and positive user reviews. XO Insert Code's mature presence makes it an easier, more reliable tool for customization using custom code.
In conclusion, a merchant looking to segment content through a no-code solution has limited option if Members Only Section works in practice as described. Other merchants needing flexibility to insert various code snippets should opt for XO Insert Code. Merchants should thoroughly research and test both apps, or potentially consider alternative content gating options before commiting to Members Only Section with its lack of reviews.
Common Questions
Does Members Only Section require coding knowledge?
No, Members Only Section is designed to work without coding, using customer tags as triggers.
Can XO Insert Code be used to restrict content to specific customers?
No, XO Insert Code is primarily for inserting code. It can potentially be used to achieve similar results through custom scripting, but it doesn't offer built-in content restriction features like Members Only Section.
Which app is easier to use for a beginner?
Members Only Section aims to be easier for beginners as it doesn't require coding. XO Insert Code is easy to insert the custom code, but relies on user's coding skill to add useful functions.
Which app is better for adding Google Analytics tracking?
XO Insert Code is the preferred solution to integrate 3rd party service like Google Analytics.
What if I need both member-only sections and custom code insertion?
You would potentially need both apps, depending on the complexity. Use Members Only Section for basic content gating, and XO Insert Code for advanced customizations and integrations, if it is functional and doesn't conflict with members-only code from other apps.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store