Members Only Section vs Progus Store Locator Mapfor Shopify (2026)
Members Only Section and Progus Store Locator Map are vastly different Shopify apps catering to distinct merchant needs. Members Only Section focuses on enhancing storefront content control by allowing merchants to create sections accessible only to tagged customer segments. Its strength lies in content gating for VIP customers or wholesale programs within a Shopify 2.0 theme, offering customizable messages and background designs. On the other hand, Progus Store Locator Map provides a solution for merchants with physical locations looking to improve customer discoverability and drive in-store sales. Its strengths are its user-friendly design, customizable map styles, and advanced analytics capabilities. The fundamental difference is in their purpose: Members Only Section enhances content visibility and customer segmentation on the online store, while Progus Store Locator Map guides customers to physical store locations. Members Only Section targets merchants seeking to create exclusive content experiences, whereas Progus Store Locator Map is geared towards businesses with brick-and-mortar stores who want to facilitate customer navigation and understand location-based customer behavior. The former improves online engagement, the latter improves offline traffic.
At a Glance
Members Only Section
0 reviews
Progus Store Locator Map
58 reviews
Detailed Overview
Members Only Section
Adds a Members only section to any 2.0 Theme page or product template.
Key Features
- Works on any Shopify 2.0 theme without coding.
- Customer tag as trigger per section (can have different tags on each section)
- Custom message to logged in customers.
Progus Store Locator Map
Experience the convenience of using our customizable & user-friendly store and dealer locator.
Key Features
- No API KEY required - quick installation without any external services
- 23k+ map styles plus custom markers, colors and fonts
- Intelligent bulk import system with Google Sheet & Shopify Locations sync
- Advanced analytics and customizable dealer registration form
- Multilingual support – translate map and location data into any language
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Members Only Section0/5 Progus Store Locator Map5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 58 |
Reviews Members Only Section0 Progus Store Locator Map58 | ||
| Primary Function | Content Restriction/Customer Segmentation | Store Location Mapping |
Primary Function Members Only SectionContent Restriction/Customer Segmentation Progus Store Locator MapStore Location Mapping | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses offering exclusive content/VIP programs | Businesses with physical retail locations |
Target Merchant Members Only SectionBusinesses offering exclusive content/VIP programs Progus Store Locator MapBusinesses with physical retail locations | ||
| Ease of Use (implied) | Potentially high (customization focused) | High (No API Key required) |
Ease of Use (implied) Members Only SectionPotentially high (customization focused) Progus Store Locator MapHigh (No API Key required) | ||
| Key Differentiator | Customer tag-based access control for content sections | Advanced analytics and customizable map styles |
Key Differentiator Members Only SectionCustomer tag-based access control for content sections Progus Store Locator MapAdvanced analytics and customizable map styles | ||
| Storefront Enhancement | Content Visibility Control | Physical Store Discovery |
Storefront Enhancement Members Only SectionContent Visibility Control Progus Store Locator MapPhysical Store Discovery | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased engagement with segmented customer groups | Increased in-store sales and customer satisfaction |
Value Proposition Members Only SectionIncreased engagement with segmented customer groups Progus Store Locator MapIncreased in-store sales and customer satisfaction | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants needing to gate specific content sections to certain customer segments based on tags (e.g., VIP content, wholesale areas), Members Only Section is a suitable choice, assuming the merchant is comfortable with a brand new app with no reviews. However, the lack of reviews makes it a risky choice.
Progus Store Locator Map is the clear choice for merchants with physical locations who want to improve customer discoverability and understand customer location trends. Its high rating and positive reviews, combined with its user-friendly features and analytics capabilities, make it a strong option for businesses with brick-and-mortar stores. Given the significant difference in user feedback and functionality, Progus Store Locator Map is the safer and generally more useful application for merchants with physical retail presence.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to install and configure?
Progus Store Locator Map explicitly states "No API KEY required - quick installation", suggesting a simpler setup process. Members Only Section mentions working "without coding", hinting at a straightforward process, but the absence of user reviews makes it difficult to definitively determine ease of use.
Can both apps be used on the same Shopify store?
Yes, both apps serve different purposes and can coexist on the same Shopify store. Members Only Section manages online content, while Progus Store Locator Map manages physical store locations. They do not directly conflict.
Which app offers better insights and analytics?
Progus Store Locator Map explicitly mentions "Advanced analytics provide valuable insights into where customers are looking for your products". Members Only Section does not mention any analytics features.
Which app is better for a purely online store?
Members Only Section is more relevant for a purely online store, as it allows for customer segmentation and exclusive content. Progus Store Locator Map is designed for businesses with physical locations and is therefore not relevant to a purely online store.
Which app offers more customization options?
While both offer customization, Members Only Section provides customization for content sections (heading, messages, colors), while Progus Store Locator Map offers customization for map styles, markers, and the dealer registration form. The "more" useful customization depends on whether you want to customize online content or store location presentation.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store