Last Login: Login Tracker and OTP Login with Phone both address Shopify accounts and login, but serve fundamentally different purposes. Last Login: Login Tracker focuses on *monitoring* user activity post-login, providing data on customer login frequency and last login date. This data is then leveraged for targeted marketing or B2B wholesale customer management. It's a tool for understanding user behavior and identifying potentially disengaged customers. OTP Login with Phone, conversely, focuses on *improving the login experience itself*. It replaces traditional passwords with one-time passwords sent via SMS or email, aiming for a faster, more secure login process. It emphasizes ease of use and account security, offering customizable settings for OTP expiry and resend limits. It also provides a more streamlined flow with optional OTP prompts on the Buy Now and Checkout buttons. The primary audience for OTP Login with Phone is merchants prioritizing security and user convenience during account creation and login, while Last Login: Login Tracker is for those focused on user engagement analysis and targeted marketing based on login activity.
7 reviews
39 reviews
Collect daily login data for all of your users. Export login data. Target high-value customers.
Enable fast, secure OTP login with phone number and email for a smooth store login experience.
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Last Login: Login Tracker5/5 OTP Login with Phone5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 7 | 39 |
Reviews Last Login: Login Tracker7 OTP Login with Phone39 | ||
| Core Functionality | Tracks user login activity and last login date | Enables OTP login via phone number or email |
Core Functionality Last Login: Login TrackerTracks user login activity and last login date OTP Login with PhoneEnables OTP login via phone number or email | ||
| Target Merchant | B2B wholesale, marketing-focused stores | Security and user experience focused stores |
Target Merchant Last Login: Login TrackerB2B wholesale, marketing-focused stores OTP Login with PhoneSecurity and user experience focused stores | ||
| Value Proposition | Data for targeted marketing and user engagement analysis | Faster, more secure login process with improved user experience |
Value Proposition Last Login: Login TrackerData for targeted marketing and user engagement analysis OTP Login with PhoneFaster, more secure login process with improved user experience | ||
| Data Export | Yes (CSV format) | No direct data export (focus on login process) |
Data Export Last Login: Login TrackerYes (CSV format) OTP Login with PhoneNo direct data export (focus on login process) | ||
| Ease of Use Emphasis | Simple tracking and export of login data. | Emphasis on customizable login flows and OTP settings for a smooth user experience. |
Ease of Use Emphasis Last Login: Login TrackerSimple tracking and export of login data. OTP Login with PhoneEmphasis on customizable login flows and OTP settings for a smooth user experience. | ||
| SMS Integration | N/A | Integrates with SMS providers like MSG91 and Firebase |
SMS Integration Last Login: Login TrackerN/A OTP Login with PhoneIntegrates with SMS providers like MSG91 and Firebase | ||
For merchants primarily concerned with understanding user behavior and targeting customers based on their login activity, especially in B2B or wholesale contexts, Last Login: Login Tracker is the better choice. Its ability to track and export login data provides valuable insights for marketing and customer management.
However, if the priority is enhancing the login experience with a focus on security and ease of use, OTP Login with Phone is the clear winner. Its OTP-based authentication provides a more secure alternative to passwords and simplifies the login process, potentially reducing cart abandonment and improving customer satisfaction. OTP Login with Phone is highly recommended if your store experiences security concerns or you want to improve the initial user login and registration flows.
OTP Login with Phone is significantly better for improving login security, as it replaces passwords with one-time codes.
Last Login: Login Tracker excels at understanding user engagement by tracking login frequency and last login date.
Yes, you can use both apps together. OTP Login with Phone handles the initial login, while Last Login: Login Tracker tracks activity *after* login.
Based on the descriptions, Last Login: Login Tracker appears to be simpler to initially set up, as it primarily focuses on tracking data. OTP Login with Phone requires configuration of OTP settings and SMS provider integrations, but should still be fairly straightforward thanks to its customization settings.
The information provided does not specify if either app offers a free trial. Merchants should check the Shopify App Store listings for the most up-to-date details.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store