Keep on Hold Wishlist vs Recurpay: Subscriptions appfor Shopify (2026)
Keep on Hold Wishlist and Recurpay: Subscriptions app, while both falling under the 'Customer Loyalty' category on Shopify, serve drastically different purposes and target distinct merchant profiles. Keep on Hold Wishlist focuses on improving conversions by enabling customers to save items for later purchase, acting as a wishlist and leveraging abandoned cart data. Its core strength lies in providing a simple save-for-later functionality and offering basic analytics on cart/wishlist activity. Recurpay, on the other hand, is a comprehensive subscription management solution aimed at unlocking recurring revenue streams. It empowers merchants to offer flexible subscription plans, manage recurring payments, and provide a robust customer portal for subscription management.
At a Glance
Keep on Hold Wishlist
5 reviews
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
400 reviews
Detailed Overview
Keep on Hold Wishlist
Keep on Hold adds Save-for-Later button to items on cart page and a wishlist button to product pages
Key Features
- Save removed cart items from the Cart page. Product page wishlist button.
- Fast and compatible with all themes. Install and enable in a just a few minutes.
- Optional login for shoppers to save their wishlist across devices.
- Reports of cart and wishlist transactions and populate products on you store.
- Boost Sales & Loyalty by allowing your shoppers to save items for later.
Recurpay: Subscriptions app
Subscriptions app to unlock recurring revenue with intuitive customer portal & 24/7 human support.
Key Features
- Support upfront and pay-as-you-go plans with flexible renewal, 24/7 live support
- Design custom subscription widget for your brand in few clicks with full access.
- Let customers manage subscriptions: skip, edit, reschedule, or cancel anytime
- Renew subscriptions on a specific day or date, offer tiered discount, free gifts
- Developer-friendly setup with full access to APIs, code & technical support
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.3/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Keep on Hold Wishlist4.3/5 Recurpay: Subscriptions app5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 5 | 400 |
Reviews Keep on Hold Wishlist5 Recurpay: Subscriptions app400 | ||
| Core Functionality | Wishlist & Cart Abandonment Recovery | Subscription Management |
Core Functionality Keep on Hold WishlistWishlist & Cart Abandonment Recovery Recurpay: Subscriptions appSubscription Management | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking basic wishlist and cart recovery features. | Merchants seeking recurring revenue through subscriptions. |
Target Merchant Keep on Hold WishlistMerchants seeking basic wishlist and cart recovery features. Recurpay: Subscriptions appMerchants seeking recurring revenue through subscriptions. | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Save removed cart items | Flexible subscription plans |
Key Feature 1 Keep on Hold WishlistSave removed cart items Recurpay: Subscriptions appFlexible subscription plans | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Product page wishlist button | Customer subscription portal |
Key Feature 2 Keep on Hold WishlistProduct page wishlist button Recurpay: Subscriptions appCustomer subscription portal | ||
| Support | Not explicitly mentioned | 24/7 live human support |
Support Keep on Hold WishlistNot explicitly mentioned Recurpay: Subscriptions app24/7 live human support | ||
| Ease of Use | Fast and compatible with all themes | Quick and easy setup |
Ease of Use Keep on Hold WishlistFast and compatible with all themes Recurpay: Subscriptions appQuick and easy setup | ||
| Value Proposition | Boost Sales & Loyalty by allowing shoppers to save items for later. | Unlock recurring revenue with intuitive customer portal & 24/7 human support. |
Value Proposition Keep on Hold WishlistBoost Sales & Loyalty by allowing shoppers to save items for later. Recurpay: Subscriptions appUnlock recurring revenue with intuitive customer portal & 24/7 human support. | ||
Our Verdict
Keep on Hold Wishlist is best suited for stores that want to implement a simple wishlist feature and recover potentially lost sales from abandoned carts. The ease of installation and compatibility with all themes makes it a quick win for small to medium-sized businesses. Recurpay is the clear choice for merchants who are serious about building a subscription-based revenue model. The comprehensive features, robust customer portal, and 24/7 support make it a powerful tool for managing subscriptions at scale, justifying its use for businesses with a strong focus on recurring revenue streams and customer management.
Common Questions
Which app focuses on recovering abandoned cart sales?
Keep on Hold Wishlist includes features that help recover sales from abandoned carts by letting shoppers save items for later.
Does either app offer customer support?
Recurpay explicitly offers 24/7 live human support. Keep on Hold Wishlist does not mention specific support details.
Which app is better for building a subscription service?
Recurpay is specifically designed for managing subscriptions and recurring revenue. It offers tools for plan creation, payment processing, and customer management within subscriptions, while Keep on Hold offers no such feature.
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps advertise ease of setup, Keep on Hold Wishlist claims to 'install and enable in just a few minutes' and is compatible with all themes, and Recurpay mentions a 'quick and easy setup'. While both claim to be fast to set up, Keep on Hold Wishlist seems to be slightly simpler in that sense.
Do both apps require Shopify login?
Keep on Hold Wishlist allows shoppers to optionally login with Shopify. Recurpay doesn't explicitly require Shopify login to manage subscriptions, but leverages Shopify's customer account feature, implying integration with Shopify's system.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store