Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails vs Selling Pointfor Shopify (2026)
Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails and Selling Point, while both listed under the 'Gifts' category on Shopify, cater to distinct merchant needs. Giftify focuses on enhancing the gifting experience with gift message emails, although its very low review count and rating suggest limited adoption or satisfaction. In contrast, Selling Point addresses a specific pain point: migrating gift cards and store credit from other platforms to Shopify. Selling Point positions itself as a time-saving solution for merchants transitioning from other POS systems or websites, or those looking to consolidate existing gift card programs, and enjoys a much higher rating and significantly more reviews, indicating greater user satisfaction and a more established presence. Selling Point's description emphasizes ease of use and cost-effectiveness in migrating gift card data to Shopify.
At a Glance
Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails
5 reviews
Selling Point
45 reviews
Detailed Overview
Selling Point
Easily migrate or import Gift Cards or Store Credits from any POS system or website into your store
Key Features
- Migrate your existing Gift Cards from any platform into Shopify Gift Cards.
- Import store credit from another system into a native Store Credit in bulk.
- Ability to import physical gift cards as virtual gift cards in bulk.
- Transform offline Gift Cards into virtual native Gift Cards/Store Credits.
- Bulk generate & auto send out Gift Cards for your marketing promotions.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 3.5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails3.5/5 Selling Point5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 5 | 45 |
Reviews Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails5 Selling Point45 | ||
| Primary Function | Gift Message Emails | Gift Card/Store Credit Migration |
Primary Function Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsGift Message Emails Selling PointGift Card/Store Credit Migration | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants wanting to add gift message functionality to emails, likely small businesses | Merchants migrating from another platform, or needing to import a large number of gift cards |
Target Merchant Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsMerchants wanting to add gift message functionality to emails, likely small businesses Selling PointMerchants migrating from another platform, or needing to import a large number of gift cards | ||
| Ease of Use (Assumed) | Likely easy to install, potentially complex setup of email templates | Focuses on Ease of Migration, aimed at being simple |
Ease of Use (Assumed) Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsLikely easy to install, potentially complex setup of email templates Selling PointFocuses on Ease of Migration, aimed at being simple | ||
| Value Proposition | Enhanced Gifting Experience | Saves time and money on gift card migration |
Value Proposition Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsEnhanced Gifting Experience Selling PointSaves time and money on gift card migration | ||
| Key Features | Gift Message Emails (not specified) | Gift Card Migration, Store Credit Import, Bulk Generation, Physical to Virtual Conversion |
Key Features Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsGift Message Emails (not specified) Selling PointGift Card Migration, Store Credit Import, Bulk Generation, Physical to Virtual Conversion | ||
| Developer Focus | N/A | Aimed to eliminate the need for custom development |
Developer Focus Giftify ‑ Gift Message EmailsN/A Selling PointAimed to eliminate the need for custom development | ||
Our Verdict
Selling Point is the clear choice for merchants needing to migrate or import gift cards or store credit into Shopify. Its high rating and numerous reviews, along with its clearly defined value proposition, suggest a reliable solution for this specific task. Giftify ‑ Gift Message Emails, with its low rating and limited adoption, presents a less compelling option unless its specific gift message email features are absolutely essential and no alternative is available. Due to the rating and review volume, merchants should approach Giftify with caution and thoroughly investigate its features before committing. If merchants want to improve the gifting experience in general, they would be better off researching apps with more reviews and higher ratings.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use?
Selling Point explicitly focuses on ease of use for gift card migration, whereas Giftify's ease of use isn't explicitly addressed in its description, making Selling Point likely the easier option for its specific purpose. However, actual ease of use can only be determined through user testing.
Which app is more suitable for a large enterprise?
Selling Point's ability to handle bulk migrations makes it potentially more suitable for larger enterprises migrating from other POS systems with a large number of gift cards. Giftify, based on the available data, doesn't seem to offer enterprise-level features.
Which app is more likely to be actively supported?
Selling Point, with its higher rating and significantly more reviews, is more likely to be actively supported due to its apparent success and customer base. However, this is speculative and depends on the developers' commitment.
If I only want to improve gift message emails, is Giftify my only option?
No, you should research other gift-related Shopify apps with more reviews and higher ratings. Giftify's low rating indicates potential issues or lack of support, so it's best to explore alternatives before committing to it.
Does Selling Point help with sending marketing emails with gift cards?
Selling Point offers bulk gift card generation and auto-sending, which could be used for marketing promotions. However, it is not specifically email marketing software. Dedicated email marketing apps will provide more comprehensive solutions.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store