Gifted: Gift Messages vs Zestard Gift Wrapfor Shopify (2026)
Gifted: Gift Messages and Zestard Gift Wrap both target Shopify merchants seeking to enhance the gifting experience on their online stores, but they approach it with slightly different focuses. Gifted centers on virtual gift messages and acquiring new customers through gift recipients, offering a more comprehensive solution that includes email delivery, upselling, and analytics. Zestard Gift Wrap, on the other hand, concentrates on physical gift wrapping options and aesthetic integration with the store's existing theme, emphasizing the visual presentation of the gift itself. Gifted positions itself as a tool for increasing customer base and driving revenue through gifting, focusing on digital experiences and customer acquisition. Its strength lies in its ability to send branded, timely gift emails, capture gift sales data, and prevent address changes on gift orders, appealing to merchants wanting more comprehensive gifting capabilities. Zestard Gift Wrap excels in providing diverse gift wrapping options and simplifying the gift wrapping process for both the admin and the customer, appealing to merchants prioritizing visually appealing gift presentation and ease of use in gift selection and purchase.
At a Glance
Gifted: Gift Messages
13 reviews
Zestard Gift Wrap
25 reviews
Detailed Overview
Gifted: Gift Messages
Increase customer base by allowing items to be sent with an virtual gift message to others
Key Features
- Capture more gift sales with our gifting widget and popup
- Send branded, timely gift emails customized to your store
- Gain new customers by redirecting gift recipients to your site
- Better understand your customers by analyzing your gift sales and data
- Prevent order-triggered changes to customers' default address on gift orders
Zestard Gift Wrap
With Zestard Gift Wrap, you can be sure that your gifts will stand out from the rest!
Key Features
- Simplify the gifting process by adding Gift Wrap to Cart Page / Product Page.
- Admin can manage gift wrap settings & wrapping options easily from one place.
- The widget has a very compact look & a sleek interface, easy to use for buyers.
- The Short code is available to paste in the dashboard with full instructions.
- The app will inherit the look and feel of the theme.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.7/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating Gifted: Gift Messages4.7/5 Zestard Gift Wrap4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 13 | 25 |
Reviews Gifted: Gift Messages13 Zestard Gift Wrap25 | ||
| Focus | Digital Gift Messages and Customer Acquisition | Physical Gift Wrapping Options |
Focus Gifted: Gift MessagesDigital Gift Messages and Customer Acquisition Zestard Gift WrapPhysical Gift Wrapping Options | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Branded Gift Emails | Gift Wrap on Cart/Product Page |
Key Feature 1 Gifted: Gift MessagesBranded Gift Emails Zestard Gift WrapGift Wrap on Cart/Product Page | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Gift Sales Analytics | Easy Admin Management of Wrapping Options |
Key Feature 2 Gifted: Gift MessagesGift Sales Analytics Zestard Gift WrapEasy Admin Management of Wrapping Options | ||
| Upselling Options | Gift Wrapping | Not explicitly stated |
Upselling Options Gifted: Gift MessagesGift Wrapping Zestard Gift WrapNot explicitly stated | ||
| Customization | Widget is customizable to brand | Inherits theme look and feel |
Customization Gifted: Gift MessagesWidget is customizable to brand Zestard Gift WrapInherits theme look and feel | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses wanting to grow customer base through gifting and track gift sales | Businesses wanting to offer visually appealing gift wrapping with easy setup |
Target Merchant Gifted: Gift MessagesBusinesses wanting to grow customer base through gifting and track gift sales Zestard Gift WrapBusinesses wanting to offer visually appealing gift wrapping with easy setup | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase order revenue through upselling and capturing gift sales | Set your store apart from competition with convenient and enjoyable gift wrapping options. |
Value Proposition Gifted: Gift MessagesIncrease order revenue through upselling and capturing gift sales Zestard Gift WrapSet your store apart from competition with convenient and enjoyable gift wrapping options. | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For Shopify merchants primarily interested in leveraging gifting as a customer acquisition tool and who value comprehensive data tracking of gift sales, Gifted: Gift Messages is the stronger choice. Its focus on branded email delivery, customer redirection, and analytics makes it a powerful marketing tool. However, merchants who prioritize offering visually appealing and diverse physical gift wrapping options with a simple, easy-to-use interface will find Zestard Gift Wrap more suitable. It offers a streamlined approach to enhancing the presentation of gifts and improving the customer experience related to gift wrapping selection.
While Zestard Gift Wrap has a slightly higher rating and more reviews, the choice ultimately depends on the merchant's specific needs and goals. If acquiring new customers through gifting is a key objective, Gifted offers a broader range of features. If focusing solely on physical gift presentation is the priority, Zestard Gift Wrap is the more appropriate solution.
Common Questions
Which app is better for acquiring new customers through gifting?
Gifted: Gift Messages is better suited for customer acquisition, as it redirects gift recipients to your site and allows for branded email delivery.
Which app offers more analytics and data tracking?
Gifted: Gift Messages provides gift sales analytics to help you better understand your customers and gift-giving trends.
Which app is easier to integrate with my store's existing theme?
Zestard Gift Wrap is designed to inherit the look and feel of your store's theme, potentially making it easier to integrate visually.
Which app offers more diverse gift wrapping options?
Zestard Gift Wrap explicitly mentions providing a variety of wrapping options.
Which app has a larger user base, based on reviews?
Zestard Gift Wrap has 25 reviews, while Gifted: Gift Messages has 13 reviews, suggesting a larger user base for Zestard.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store