Filljoy Order Catch Weights vs Yagi Address Edit Helperfor Shopify (2026)
Filljoy Order Catch Weights and Yagi Address Edit Helper both address order editing needs on Shopify, but cater to entirely different problems and merchant types. Filljoy focuses on enabling merchants selling variable-weight products like meat, seafood, and produce to accurately fulfill orders and charge customers based on the actual weight of the items shipped. This is crucial for maintaining profitability and customer satisfaction in industries where portioning is inherently imprecise. The app's primary value proposition is preventing under or overcharging, ensuring fair transactions for both the merchant and the customer. Yagi Address Edit Helper, on the other hand, tackles address-related fulfillment issues by empowering customers to self-edit shipping addresses after placing an order. This reduces customer support workload and minimizes the risk of failed deliveries due to incorrect address information. Its strengths lie in improving the post-purchase customer experience and streamlining shipping logistics.
At a Glance
Filljoy Order Catch Weights
3 reviews
Yagi Address Edit Helper
12 reviews
Detailed Overview
Filljoy Order Catch Weights
Enable precise order fulfillment for products sold by catch weight such as meat, seafood and dairy.
Key Features
- Input the exact weights of line items to edit and fulfill paid online orders
- Edit draft orders to send accurate invoices to customers for payment
- Edits are automatically applied to the original Shopify order or draft order
Yagi Address Edit Helper
The app allows customer to update shipping address on their own, without need to contact support
Key Features
- Let customer update order shipping address on their own
- Set time limit, eg: customer can only update address within 2 days of order
- Disallow shipping address amendment on certain product / orders with tag
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Filljoy Order Catch Weights5/5 Yagi Address Edit Helper5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 3 | 12 |
Reviews Filljoy Order Catch Weights3 Yagi Address Edit Helper12 | ||
| Primary Function | Precise weight-based order fulfillment | Customer self-service address editing |
Primary Function Filljoy Order Catch WeightsPrecise weight-based order fulfillment Yagi Address Edit HelperCustomer self-service address editing | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses selling catch weight products (meat, seafood, produce) | Any merchant concerned about address errors and support burden |
Target Merchant Filljoy Order Catch WeightsBusinesses selling catch weight products (meat, seafood, produce) Yagi Address Edit HelperAny merchant concerned about address errors and support burden | ||
| Key Feature: Order Editing | Input exact weights for accurate pricing | Customers update address on order status/account page |
Key Feature: Order Editing Filljoy Order Catch WeightsInput exact weights for accurate pricing Yagi Address Edit HelperCustomers update address on order status/account page | ||
| Integration | Edits applied to Shopify orders/draft orders | Integrates with order status and account pages |
Integration Filljoy Order Catch WeightsEdits applied to Shopify orders/draft orders Yagi Address Edit HelperIntegrates with order status and account pages | ||
| Flexibility | Specifically designed for catch weight products | Time limit & product tag restrictions for address changes |
Flexibility Filljoy Order Catch WeightsSpecifically designed for catch weight products Yagi Address Edit HelperTime limit & product tag restrictions for address changes | ||
| Limitation | Not compatible with Shopify Local Delivery orders | N/A |
Limitation Filljoy Order Catch WeightsNot compatible with Shopify Local Delivery orders Yagi Address Edit HelperN/A | ||
| Value Proposition | Fair pricing for variable weight products | Reduced customer support and shipping errors |
Value Proposition Filljoy Order Catch WeightsFair pricing for variable weight products Yagi Address Edit HelperReduced customer support and shipping errors | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants selling products with variable weights requiring precise pricing, Filljoy Order Catch Weights is the clear choice. Its weight-based editing functionality is essential for businesses in the food and agriculture sectors to ensure accurate invoicing and prevent revenue loss. The app directly addresses the challenges unique to catch weight items. Yagi Address Edit Helper, on the other hand, is beneficial for a wider range of e-commerce businesses experiencing frequent address-related issues and wanting to reduce customer support inquiries. If your business ships frequently and incorrect addresses are a common problem, Yagi offers a valuable self-service solution to improve customer experience and prevent costly shipping errors.
Common Questions
Can Filljoy Order Catch Weights be used for products sold by volume instead of weight?
While Filljoy Order Catch Weights focuses on weight-based pricing adjustments, its core functionality of editing line item details could potentially be adapted for volume-based products. However, it's primarily designed for catch weight scenarios, and its features might not be optimally suited for volume-specific needs.
Does Yagi Address Edit Helper work for international orders?
The description doesn't explicitly mention international orders, but the core functionality of allowing address updates should generally apply regardless of the shipping destination, provided the Shopify store is configured to handle international addresses.
How does Filljoy Order Catch Weights handle refunds or price adjustments after fulfillment?
The description doesn't specify how refunds are handled after fulfillment. Merchants would likely need to manage refunds separately based on their store's refund policy and Shopify's refund process.
Can customers use Yagi Address Edit Helper to change the name on the shipping address?
The description specifies that the app allows customers to update the 'shipping address'. It does not explicitly mention the 'name' on the address, it can be infered the name might be a part of the address that can be updated.
If I sell both catch weight items and standard products, do I need both apps?
Potentially. If you experience address issues, Yagi Address Edit Helper can benefit all orders. However, Filljoy Order Catch Weights functionality is only relevant to the catch-weight items. If only catch-weight items need order edits, only Filljoy is needed.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store