In 2026, Shopify merchants considering shipping insurance apps face a choice between ESTS Shipping Insurance and Sam Shipping Protection Upsell. ESTS Shipping Insurance aims to provide a solution to boost customer confidence and safeguard shipments through cart-integrated insurance and admin-controlled customization. However, with a complete lack of reviews, it's difficult to validate these claims. Sam Shipping Protection Upsell, on the other hand, focuses on giving merchants control over their shipping protection program by offering customizable coverage options, a self-serve claims portal, and multi-language/currency support. It positions itself as a profit-generating tool without revenue sharing, which is a key differentiator. The fundamental difference lies in demonstrable real-world usage. Sam Shipping Protection Upsell has a strong 5/5 rating from 24 reviews, suggesting existing merchant satisfaction. While ESTS Shipping Insurance promises valuable features, its zero rating and lack of reviews make it an unproven option. Sam is clearly focused on offering flexibility and brand alignment with its customizable widgets and plans, whereas ESTS is more focused on broad features like cart integration and admin control without much detail. The focus of Sam on enabling merchants to directly manage and profit from shipping protection is a clear differentiator from ESTS' more generic approach.
0 reviews
24 reviews
Enhance customer confidence and protect purchases with our Shipping Insurance App. Easily
Take Control of Shipping Protection — Build Trust & Create a Better Shopping Experience
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating ESTS Shipping Insurance0/5 Sam Shipping Protection Upsell5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 24 |
Reviews ESTS Shipping Insurance0 Sam Shipping Protection Upsell24 | ||
| Customization | Admin-Controlled Customization | Customizable widget, Flexible protection plans |
Customization ESTS Shipping InsuranceAdmin-Controlled Customization Sam Shipping Protection UpsellCustomizable widget, Flexible protection plans | ||
| Claim Handling | Not specified | Easy self-serve claims portal |
Claim Handling ESTS Shipping InsuranceNot specified Sam Shipping Protection UpsellEasy self-serve claims portal | ||
| Pricing Model | Transparent Coverage Costs | No middlemen. No revenue sharing |
Pricing Model ESTS Shipping InsuranceTransparent Coverage Costs Sam Shipping Protection UpsellNo middlemen. No revenue sharing | ||
| Global Support | Not specified | Supports multiple languages and currencies |
Global Support ESTS Shipping InsuranceNot specified Sam Shipping Protection UpsellSupports multiple languages and currencies | ||
| Ease of Use | Seamless Shopify Integration (Implied) | Fits naturally into your store, smoother experience |
Ease of Use ESTS Shipping InsuranceSeamless Shopify Integration (Implied) Sam Shipping Protection UpsellFits naturally into your store, smoother experience | ||
| Value Proposition | Enhance customer confidence and protect purchases | Build trust, Create a better shopping experience, more profit |
Value Proposition ESTS Shipping InsuranceEnhance customer confidence and protect purchases Sam Shipping Protection UpsellBuild trust, Create a better shopping experience, more profit | ||
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell, with its proven track record and flexible features, is the more compelling choice for most Shopify merchants in 2026. Its existing user base and clear focus on merchant control and profitability make it a safer bet. Merchants prioritizing brand alignment and direct profit from shipping protection should strongly consider Sam.
ESTS Shipping Insurance, while promising, is a significant risk due to the lack of reviews. It might be suitable only for merchants willing to take a chance on an unproven app, perhaps with a very specific need its features uniquely address. However, it's hard to recommend ESTS given the absence of any validation of its claimed capabilities or user experience.
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell is significantly more proven, with a 5/5 rating and 24 reviews, compared to ESTS Shipping Insurance's 0/5 rating and zero reviews.
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell offers greater control through flexible protection plans, customizable widgets, and a self-serve claims portal, allowing merchants to directly manage and brand their protection program.
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell explicitly supports multiple languages and currencies, making it suitable for international businesses. ESTS Shipping Insurance does not mention global support.
Sam Shipping Protection Upsell is designed to increase profits, with no revenue sharing. ESTS Shipping Insurance only promises to protect purchases, without a clear statement of impact on profitability.
Based on the descriptions, Sam Shipping Protection Upsell appears to offer a smoother and more natural integration into the Shopify store. However, both apps claim seamless Shopify integration, but the ease of use is only validated for Sam by its reviews.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store