ESTS Shipping Insurance vs PMO: ProtectMyOrderfor Shopify (2026)
ESTS Shipping Insurance and PMO: ProtectMyOrder both target Shopify merchants looking to offer shipping-related protection to their customers, but they operate under very different models. ESTS Shipping Insurance positions itself as a solution to instill customer confidence and safeguard shipments, emphasizing features like cart integration and admin-controlled customization. It seems to be geared towards merchants who want complete control over their insurance offerings and are willing to handle claims themselves (although this isn't explicitly stated, the description leans in this direction). PMO: ProtectMyOrder, on the other hand, is designed for merchants who want to generate revenue by upselling premium services, including shipping protection, carbon-neutral shipping, and free returns. Its key differentiator is the revenue-sharing model (merchant keeps 80%), with PMO handling claims. The focus is on ease of use, rapid implementation, and maximizing Average Order Value (AOV). The target audience appears to be merchants who prioritize revenue generation and prefer a hands-off approach to claims management.
At a Glance
ESTS Shipping Insurance
0 reviews
PMO: ProtectMyOrder
13 reviews
Detailed Overview
ESTS Shipping Insurance
Enhance customer confidence and protect purchases with our Shipping Insurance App. Easily
Key Features
- Cart-Integrated Insurance
- Admin-Controlled Customization:
- Seamless Shopify Integration
- Transparent Coverage Costs
PMO: ProtectMyOrder
Upsell premium services at checkout: increase AOV and improve customer experience
Key Features
- With 9 clicks, start selling premium services like package protection
- Show to 50% of site traffic to see impact on conversion rate
- Customise everything: pricing, titles, text and images
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating ESTS Shipping Insurance0/5 PMO: ProtectMyOrder5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 13 |
Reviews ESTS Shipping Insurance0 PMO: ProtectMyOrder13 | ||
| Business Model | Insurance Solution (Implied direct insurance) | Upselling Premium Services (Revenue Share) |
Business Model ESTS Shipping InsuranceInsurance Solution (Implied direct insurance) PMO: ProtectMyOrderUpselling Premium Services (Revenue Share) | ||
| Claims Handling | Merchant (Implied) | PMO Handles Claims |
Claims Handling ESTS Shipping InsuranceMerchant (Implied) PMO: ProtectMyOrderPMO Handles Claims | ||
| Revenue Generation | Not the primary focus | Primary focus - upsell revenue |
Revenue Generation ESTS Shipping InsuranceNot the primary focus PMO: ProtectMyOrderPrimary focus - upsell revenue | ||
| Customization | Admin-Controlled Customization | Customizable pricing, titles, text, and images |
Customization ESTS Shipping InsuranceAdmin-Controlled Customization PMO: ProtectMyOrderCustomizable pricing, titles, text, and images | ||
| Ease of Use | Not specified | 9 clicks to start selling |
Ease of Use ESTS Shipping InsuranceNot specified PMO: ProtectMyOrder9 clicks to start selling | ||
| Integration | Seamless Shopify Integration | Show to 50% of site traffic for impact analysis |
Integration ESTS Shipping InsuranceSeamless Shopify Integration PMO: ProtectMyOrderShow to 50% of site traffic for impact analysis | ||
Our Verdict
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is the clear choice for merchants seeking a quick, revenue-generating solution with minimal effort on their part. The 5-star rating and 13 reviews, combined with the revenue-sharing model and claims handling by PMO, make it a compelling option for those prioritizing AOV and customer experience. ESTS Shipping Insurance, on the other hand, is a riskier choice given the lack of reviews. However, it *might* be suitable for merchants who need very specific control over insurance policies and are willing to manage claims internally. But given the absence of reviews and the vagueness of the description, proceeding with ESTS is highly uncertain in 2026. Unless ESTS gains traction and builds a strong user base, PMO: ProtectMyOrder is the significantly stronger choice.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is designed for quick setup, claiming that merchants can start selling premium services with just 9 clicks. There is no information about ESTS Shipping Insurance's ease of setup, making PMO the easier choice based on available data.
Which app handles claims?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder handles all claims. ESTS Shipping Insurance does not explicitly state claims handling, but the description suggests that merchants would handle the claims themselves.
Which app is better for increasing revenue?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder is specifically designed to increase revenue through upselling premium services, with merchants keeping 80% of the upsell revenue. ESTS Shipping Insurance focuses on customer confidence and doesn't directly address revenue generation.
Which app offers more customization options?
Both apps offer customization. ESTS Shipping Insurance offers "Admin-Controlled Customization". PMO: ProtectMyOrder allows you to customise pricing, titles, text and images. While both allow customization, it is difficult to gauge which has more flexibility without further information.
Which app is more reputable?
PMO: ProtectMyOrder has a 5/5 rating with 13 reviews, indicating established user satisfaction. ESTS Shipping Insurance has no reviews, making PMO the more reputable option.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store