In 2026, Essential Trust Badges & Icons and Sharely: Social Media Icons both maintain perfect 5/5 ratings, but cater to distinct needs within the Shopify ecosystem. Essential Trust Badges focuses on building customer trust and increasing conversions through visual cues like product badges, trust badges, and payment icons, positioning itself as a comprehensive solution for enhancing website credibility. It appeals to merchants seeking to directly influence purchase decisions on product pages by highlighting guarantees, discounts, and security measures. Its strength lies in the extensive customization options for badge design and placement. Sharely: Social Media Icons, on the other hand, prioritizes expanding a store's reach and enhancing social proof through prominent social media links and share buttons. It directly aims to drive traffic to the merchant's social media profiles and encourage product sharing, thereby broadening the store's online presence. The app's key advantage is its support for an unlimited number of social media platforms, including emerging networks alongside established giants. The target audience is merchants who actively engage with social media and view it as a vital component of their marketing strategy.
554 reviews
96 reviews
Show features & guarantees with product badge icons, trust badges banners, stickers & product labels
Add social media icons or social share buttons, giving your store credibility and widespread sharing
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Essential Trust Badges & Icons5/5 Sharely: Social Media Icons5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 554 | 96 |
Reviews Essential Trust Badges & Icons554 Sharely: Social Media Icons96 | ||
| Primary Focus | On-site Trust & Conversions | Social Media Engagement & Sharing |
Primary Focus Essential Trust Badges & IconsOn-site Trust & Conversions Sharely: Social Media IconsSocial Media Engagement & Sharing | ||
| Badge Types | Trust Badges, Product Labels, Payment Icons | Social Media Icons & Sharing Buttons |
Badge Types Essential Trust Badges & IconsTrust Badges, Product Labels, Payment Icons Sharely: Social Media IconsSocial Media Icons & Sharing Buttons | ||
| Customization | Extensive customization of badges, icons, and placement. | Flexible design and icon styles. |
Customization Essential Trust Badges & IconsExtensive customization of badges, icons, and placement. Sharely: Social Media IconsFlexible design and icon styles. | ||
| Social Media Support | Payment Icons only. | Unlimited Social Media Platforms |
Social Media Support Essential Trust Badges & IconsPayment Icons only. Sharely: Social Media IconsUnlimited Social Media Platforms | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants prioritizing on-site trust signals and direct conversion optimization. | Merchants actively using social media for marketing and brand building. |
Target Merchant Essential Trust Badges & IconsMerchants prioritizing on-site trust signals and direct conversion optimization. Sharely: Social Media IconsMerchants actively using social media for marketing and brand building. | ||
| Value Proposition | Build trust and credibility with visually appealing badges and icons. | Increase social media presence and drive traffic through social sharing. |
Value Proposition Essential Trust Badges & IconsBuild trust and credibility with visually appealing badges and icons. Sharely: Social Media IconsIncrease social media presence and drive traffic through social sharing. | ||
For Shopify merchants prioritizing immediate trust-building elements on their product pages to directly impact conversions, Essential Trust Badges & Icons is the superior choice. The app's comprehensive customization options, extensive badge library, and focus on guarantees and security provide a robust toolkit for boosting perceived credibility.
However, if a merchant's primary goal is to expand their social media presence, drive traffic to their social profiles, and encourage product sharing, Sharely: Social Media Icons is the better option. Its support for an unlimited number of social media platforms and dedicated focus on social sharing features make it ideal for businesses with a strong social media marketing strategy.
Essential Trust Badges & Icons provides a broader range of customization options, allowing merchants to edit size, font, color, and even upload custom icons.
Essential Trust Badges & Icons would be a better fit as it focuses on on-site elements rather than social media integration.
Neither app description explicitly mentions A/B testing features.
While both apps have good ratings, the complexity of customization in Essential Trust Badges might make Sharely, with its simpler focus, slightly easier to set up initially.
The app descriptions do not address site speed. Merchants should consider testing both apps on their stores, monitoring load times, and reviewing recent customer feedback for performance-related issues prior to long term use.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store