EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift and Octolize Shipping Discounts are both highly-rated (5/5) Shopify apps in the Discounts category, but they address very different aspects of incentivizing customer purchases. EG Auto Add to Cart focuses on boosting average order value and encouraging product discovery by automatically adding free gifts or offering BOGO/Buy X Get Y deals based on cart contents or value. Its core functionality revolves around product-based incentives and automated upsells. Octolize Shipping Discounts, conversely, is focused on reducing cart abandonment and rewarding customer loyalty by automatically applying flexible shipping discounts based on a wide range of conditions, from cart total to customer location. It provides granular control over shipping costs, influencing purchasing decisions by reducing or eliminating shipping fees under specific conditions. The key difference lies in the type of incentive. EG Auto Add to Cart uses product-based incentives (free gifts, BOGO deals), while Octolize Shipping Discounts leverages shipping cost reduction. The large disparity in review counts (762 vs. 26) suggests EG Auto Add to Cart has a significantly larger user base and has been around longer, potentially indicating greater maturity and broader applicability, though it could also reflect different marketing strategies. Both apps emphasize ease of use, but their target merchants likely differ based on their primary goal: product-based upsells vs. shipping-cost-related cart abandonment reduction.
762 reviews
26 reviews
EasyGift: Free gift with purchase app for auto add to cart automatic gift, BOGO & Buy X Get Y offer
Apply shipping discounts automatically with flexible checkout rules based on various conditions
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift5/5 Octolize Shipping Discounts5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 762 | 26 |
Reviews EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift762 Octolize Shipping Discounts26 | ||
| Incentive Type | Product-Based (Free Gifts, BOGO) | Shipping Cost Reduction |
Incentive Type EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftProduct-Based (Free Gifts, BOGO) Octolize Shipping DiscountsShipping Cost Reduction | ||
| Primary Goal | Increase Average Order Value, Product Discovery | Reduce Cart Abandonment, Reward Loyalty |
Primary Goal EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftIncrease Average Order Value, Product Discovery Octolize Shipping DiscountsReduce Cart Abandonment, Reward Loyalty | ||
| Rule Complexity | Rules based on cart contents and value | Multiple combinable rules (22 conditions) |
Rule Complexity EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftRules based on cart contents and value Octolize Shipping DiscountsMultiple combinable rules (22 conditions) | ||
| Upselling Focus | Strong emphasis on upsells and BOGO offers | Indirect impact on sales through shipping incentives |
Upselling Focus EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftStrong emphasis on upsells and BOGO offers Octolize Shipping DiscountsIndirect impact on sales through shipping incentives | ||
| Ease of Use Claim | Super simple UI, easy rule creation | Easy setup, user-friendly interface |
Ease of Use Claim EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftSuper simple UI, easy rule creation Octolize Shipping DiscountsEasy setup, user-friendly interface | ||
| Integration Focus | Add to cart, no specific mention of other integrations | Seamless integration with your store |
Integration Focus EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftAdd to cart, no specific mention of other integrations Octolize Shipping DiscountsSeamless integration with your store | ||
| Scheduling | Schedule start time | Not specified |
Scheduling EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftSchedule start time Octolize Shipping DiscountsNot specified | ||
| Free gift with purchase | Yes | No |
Free gift with purchase EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftYes Octolize Shipping DiscountsNo | ||
For merchants primarily focused on boosting average order value and driving product discovery through free gifts, BOGO offers, and automated upsells, EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is the clear choice. Its focus on product-based incentives and a large user base suggest it's a proven solution for this purpose. However, if the primary goal is to reduce cart abandonment and reward customer loyalty by offering flexible shipping discounts based on a wide range of conditions, Octolize Shipping Discounts is the better option. Its granular control over shipping costs and ability to combine multiple rules offer a more tailored approach to shipping incentives. While its smaller user base may indicate it's newer or more niche, its feature set directly addresses shipping-related conversion issues. Ultimately, choose based on your biggest pain point: low average order value or high cart abandonment due to shipping costs.
Technically, yes, but it could potentially confuse customers if they are presented with too many incentives simultaneously. It's generally recommended to focus on one type of incentive at a time to avoid overwhelming shoppers.
The description primarily highlights conditions based on cart total and specific products or collections. While it mentions "custom rules," the level of complexity is not explicitly detailed, so it might be less versatile than Octolize Shipping Discounts in terms of condition combinations.
Octolize Shipping Discounts can auto-apply percentage off & fixed amount shipping discounts or even create new shipping rates, in addition to offering free shipping.
Neither app explicitly mentions built-in A/B testing capabilities. You'd likely need to use a separate A/B testing app or manually track results to compare the effectiveness of different offers created with each app.
EG Auto Add to Cart does not explicitly state support for location based pricing in its description. Octolize Shipping Discounts supports discounts based on address, implying location-based targeting, but location-based *pricing* is not explicitly confirmed.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store