In 2026, merchants choosing a Shopify donations app have a stark contrast between Donatly: Donate At POS and Lift: Charity and Donations. Donatly focuses on a basic 'donate at checkout' functionality primarily designed for Point of Sale systems. Its description highlights quick access, default donations, and reporting, suggesting a simple solution for merchants who want to add basic donation options within their POS system. However, it lacks user reviews and ratings, indicating potential risk and uncertainty. On the other hand, Lift: Charity and Donations positions itself as a comprehensive solution for both nonprofits and businesses wanting to integrate charitable giving into their brand. Lift offers flexible donation options like round-ups, custom amounts, and match-funding, along with strong multi-channel support (including POS). Its positive user rating and initial reviews signal potential for a more reliable and feature-rich donation platform. Lift is clearly targeting a broader audience that wants a more sophisticated and integrated donation experience, while Donatly seems to focus solely on a quick POS implementation. The biggest difference lies in target user and features. Donatly seems primarily for physical store environments needing basic POS donations. Lift aims for everyone, including those actively raising funds themselves (NGOs) and looking for online store and POS options, with more customization.
0 reviews
5 reviews
Donate at checkout
Give with Lift - support charities and non-profits with flexible, seamless donation tools.
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Donatly: Donate At POS0/5 Lift: Charity and Donations5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 5 |
Reviews Donatly: Donate At POS0 Lift: Charity and Donations5 | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses needing basic POS donations | Nonprofits & businesses seeking integrated online/POS donations |
Target Merchant Donatly: Donate At POSBusinesses needing basic POS donations Lift: Charity and DonationsNonprofits & businesses seeking integrated online/POS donations | ||
| Donation Options | Percentage & fixed amounts | Round-ups, custom amounts, tiers, match-funding |
Donation Options Donatly: Donate At POSPercentage & fixed amounts Lift: Charity and DonationsRound-ups, custom amounts, tiers, match-funding | ||
| Ease of Use (Inferred) | Potentially simpler setup due to fewer features | Potentially steeper learning curve due to advanced features |
Ease of Use (Inferred) Donatly: Donate At POSPotentially simpler setup due to fewer features Lift: Charity and DonationsPotentially steeper learning curve due to advanced features | ||
| Value Proposition | Simple POS donation integration | Comprehensive charitable giving platform for brand enhancement and fundraising |
Value Proposition Donatly: Donate At POSSimple POS donation integration Lift: Charity and DonationsComprehensive charitable giving platform for brand enhancement and fundraising | ||
| Multi-Channel Support | Primarily POS focused | Online Store and Shopify POS |
Multi-Channel Support Donatly: Donate At POSPrimarily POS focused Lift: Charity and DonationsOnline Store and Shopify POS | ||
| Customization | Limited customization beyond donation reasons and default amounts. | Highly customizable donation widgets and options. |
Customization Donatly: Donate At POSLimited customization beyond donation reasons and default amounts. Lift: Charity and DonationsHighly customizable donation widgets and options. | ||
For merchants needing a very basic donation option within their Shopify Point of Sale system, and who are comfortable with trying an unrated and unreviewed app, Donatly: Donate At POS might suffice. However, its lack of reviews presents a significant risk. If a merchant needs a reliable, feature-rich solution for both online and POS donations, particularly if they are a nonprofit or brand seeking to integrate charitable giving deeply into their customer experience, then Lift: Charity and Donations is the superior choice. Its positive rating and comprehensive feature set make it a much safer and more versatile option.
Considering the information available, Lift is the stronger recommendation for most Shopify merchants due to its proven performance and comprehensive features. Donatly might be suitable for a very specific, limited use case where simplicity is paramount, but the risk associated with its lack of reviews and limited features should be carefully considered.
Donatly likely has a simpler setup due to its fewer features. Lift, while more powerful, likely requires more configuration to utilize its diverse donation options.
Lift is explicitly designed for nonprofits and mission-driven brands, offering features like direct fundraising and customizable donation tiers that cater to their specific needs. Donatly lacks these features.
The description primarily focuses on POS functionality, suggesting limited or no online store donation support. Lift explicitly supports both online store and POS donations.
Both apps mention reporting, but Lift's description uses the phrase 'clear reports on donations and payments', which hints at more comprehensive reporting features. Donatly simply states 'reports'.
Lift offers a 'match-funding' feature, allowing for donation matching campaigns. Donatly does not mention this feature.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store