Craftly Checkout Rules and EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift, while both boasting perfect 5/5 ratings, cater to distinct Shopify merchant needs. Craftly focuses on optimizing and securing the checkout process through advanced rules governing payments, shipping, discounts, and fraud prevention. It aims to provide a smooth, safe, and reliable checkout experience by offering granular control without requiring coding expertise. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift, on the other hand, is laser-focused on boosting sales via automated free gifts, BOGO offers, and Buy X Get Y promotions, essentially offering an automatic upsell tool with scheduling and targeting capabilities. The key difference lies in their core function. Craftly acts as a checkout enhancer and security layer, preventing errors and potential fraud while offering customization of payment and shipping options. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift serves as a marketing automation tool to incentivize purchases and increase average order value through strategically deployed free gifts and bundled offers. While both technically offer 'discounts', Craftly's discount system is broader, applying to orders and shipping, while EG's focuses specifically on free gift or BOGO-type promotions.
8 reviews
762 reviews
Validate checkout with smart rules, customize payment and shipping methods, and offer discounts
EasyGift: Free gift with purchase app for auto add to cart automatic gift, BOGO & Buy X Get Y offer
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Craftly Checkout Rules5/5 EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 8 | 762 |
Reviews Craftly Checkout Rules8 EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift762 | ||
| Core Function | Checkout Optimization & Security | Automated Free Gifts & Promotions |
Core Function Craftly Checkout RulesCheckout Optimization & Security EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftAutomated Free Gifts & Promotions | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants needing checkout security, custom payment/shipping rules, and precise discount controls | Merchants seeking to increase average order value and customer engagement through automated offers |
Target Merchant Craftly Checkout RulesMerchants needing checkout security, custom payment/shipping rules, and precise discount controls EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftMerchants seeking to increase average order value and customer engagement through automated offers | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | High (No Coding Required) | High (Super Simple UI) |
Ease of Use (Implied) Craftly Checkout RulesHigh (No Coding Required) EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftHigh (Super Simple UI) | ||
| Fraud Prevention | Yes (Block risky COD orders) | No |
Fraud Prevention Craftly Checkout RulesYes (Block risky COD orders) EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftNo | ||
| Rule Complexity | 100+ Advanced Rules, Regex Support | Rules based on Cart Total or Specific Products |
Rule Complexity Craftly Checkout Rules100+ Advanced Rules, Regex Support EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftRules based on Cart Total or Specific Products | ||
| Discount Type | Order and Shipping Discounts | Free Gift & BOGO Offers |
Discount Type Craftly Checkout RulesOrder and Shipping Discounts EG Auto Add to Cart Free GiftFree Gift & BOGO Offers | ||
For merchants prioritizing checkout security, advanced customization of payment and shipping methods, and fine-grained discount control, Craftly Checkout Rules is the clear choice. The low number of reviews should be investigated. If the app is new, its functionality is extremely pertinent to certain businesses. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is more suitable for merchants focused on boosting sales through automatic free gifts and promotional offers. The high review count suggests strong user satisfaction and reliability in its niche. If your main goal is increasing average order value through incentivized purchases, EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is the better option.
Ultimately, the choice depends on the specific needs of the store. Both apps appear easy to use and provide value within their respective domains. However, a merchant aiming to build a smooth, reliable checkout experience and reduce fraud would choose Craftly, while one looking to increase order value through automated free gifts would choose EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift.
Craftly Checkout Rules is explicitly designed to block risky COD orders and reduce fraud using smart, regex-ready rules, while EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift does not offer fraud prevention features.
Yes, both apps offer discount capabilities, but they differ significantly. Craftly provides more flexible discount options for orders and shipping. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift focuses specifically on free gift and BOGO style promotions.
Both apps claim ease of use. Craftly emphasizes 'no coding required,' and EG highlights a 'super simple UI.' However, with only 8 reviews, Craftly's ease of use is less clearly validated than EG's 762.
Craftly Checkout Rules allows you to hide, sort, or rename shipping methods based on advanced rules, providing greater control over the shipping options presented to customers. EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift does not offer shipping customization features.
EG Auto Add to Cart Free Gift is specifically designed for this type of scenario. It allows you to automatically add a free gift to the cart when the cart total exceeds a certain value. While Craftly *might* achieve a similar result through complex discount rules, EG is the more direct and intended solution.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store