COLY ‑ Additional Order Form vs OPTIS Product Options, Variantfor Shopify (2026)
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form and OPTIS Product Options, Variant both aim to enhance product customization on Shopify stores, but cater to different needs and scales. COLY positions itself as a solution for collecting specific product customization details *before* checkout using custom fields, focusing on order form-based customization. Its strength lies in its array of field types (text field, select, date picker, etc.), display conditions, and export functionality. It's likely aimed at merchants who need to gather very specific and varied information for order fulfillment, possibly in niche or personalized product categories. OPTIS Product Options, Variant, on the other hand, is a more broadly adopted and likely more mature product options app, evidenced by its significantly higher number of reviews. While both fall under the "Custom products" and "Product variants" categories, OPTIS likely offers a wider range of standard variant options and customization capabilities beyond just pre-checkout form fields.
At a Glance
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form
2 reviews
OPTIS Product Options, Variant
1,536 reviews
Detailed Overview
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form
Collect product customization details with custom fields before checkout
Key Features
- 9 field types: Textfield, select, date picker, radio box, checkbox & more
- Form validations: Mandatory fields, minimum and maximum characters
- Display conditions: Display on selected product by product, vendor, type and tag
- Export order line properties to CSV or XLSX excel file
- Theme app extension: Customise your form to match your theme design
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating COLY ‑ Additional Order Form5/5 OPTIS Product Options, Variant5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 2 | 1536 |
Reviews COLY ‑ Additional Order Form2 OPTIS Product Options, Variant1536 | ||
| Focus | Pre-Checkout Customization Forms | Product Options & Variants |
Focus COLY ‑ Additional Order FormPre-Checkout Customization Forms OPTIS Product Options, VariantProduct Options & Variants | ||
| Field Types | 9 (Text, Select, Date, etc.) | Likely broad variant options (unspecified, inferable) |
Field Types COLY ‑ Additional Order Form9 (Text, Select, Date, etc.) OPTIS Product Options, VariantLikely broad variant options (unspecified, inferable) | ||
| Target Merchant | Niche products needing detailed customization info | Broad range of merchants selling customizable products |
Target Merchant COLY ‑ Additional Order FormNiche products needing detailed customization info OPTIS Product Options, VariantBroad range of merchants selling customizable products | ||
| Social Proof | Very limited | Extensive |
Social Proof COLY ‑ Additional Order FormVery limited OPTIS Product Options, VariantExtensive | ||
| Ease of Use (Implied) | Potentially steeper learning curve for complex forms | Likely more user-friendly due to wider adoption |
Ease of Use (Implied) COLY ‑ Additional Order FormPotentially steeper learning curve for complex forms OPTIS Product Options, VariantLikely more user-friendly due to wider adoption | ||
| Value Proposition | Highly specific pre-checkout data collection | Robust product variant and option management |
Value Proposition COLY ‑ Additional Order FormHighly specific pre-checkout data collection OPTIS Product Options, VariantRobust product variant and option management | ||
Our Verdict
If your primary need is to collect detailed, highly specific information *before* the checkout process using a custom form with diverse field types and display conditions, then COLY ‑ Additional Order Form might be a good starting point. However, given its limited number of reviews, you should proceed with caution and carefully evaluate its functionality against your exact requirements. For a more general and established solution for product options and variants, with extensive community support and a potentially broader range of features, OPTIS Product Options, Variant is the safer and likely more robust choice, especially for merchants looking for standard variant customizations and handling a larger volume of orders. Smaller stores with very specific needs could consider COLY, but larger stores will be better served with OPTIS.
Common Questions
Is COLY ‑ Additional Order Form easier to set up than OPTIS Product Options, Variant?
Without direct experience or more data, it's difficult to definitively say. OPTIS has a higher review count which suggests an easier setup. COLY's form builder could have a learning curve depending on the complexity of the required forms.
Does OPTIS Product Options, Variant offer pre-checkout customization data collection?
While OPTIS focuses on product variants and options, it's not explicitly stated if it provides pre-checkout form-based customization in the same way as COLY. Further research would be required to confirm if OPTIS can handle that specific use case.
Which app is better for a store selling personalized gifts?
Potentially COLY. If personalization requires collecting complex details (names, dates, messages) using specific input types, COLY's pre-checkout form builder with its diverse field types could be ideal. However, review count is important to note.
Which app is better for a store with a large product catalog and many variants?
OPTIS Product Options, Variant, due to its established user base (1536 reviews), suggests a more scalable and robust solution for managing a large number of product variants. COLY is likely less suited for larger catalogs.
Can both apps export order data including customizations?
COLY explicitly mentions exporting order line properties to CSV or XLSX. OPTIS doesn't explicitly state it in the provided description, but it's a common feature for variant apps. Further research is needed.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store