Color Swatch King: Variants vs COLY ‑ Additional Order Formfor Shopify (2026)
Color Swatch King: Variants and COLY - Additional Order Form, while both operating within the 'Custom Products' and 'Product Variants' categories on Shopify, cater to distinct merchant needs. Color Swatch King focuses primarily on enhancing the visual presentation and user experience of product variants, aiming to streamline the selection process and boost conversion rates through features like color swatches, variant images, and streamlined collection page browsing. Its strength lies in improving the front-end user interface related to variant selection. COLY, conversely, addresses the need for gathering additional product customization details *before* checkout. It provides tools to create custom order forms with various field types and validations, allowing merchants to collect specific information required for personalization or custom orders. While Color Swatch King improves the selection process, COLY enhances data gathering and manages the details collected. Therefore, COLY’s target audience is merchants selling personalized, configurable, or custom-made products that require specific client input before an order can be processed.
At a Glance
Color Swatch King: Variants
1,959 reviews
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form
2 reviews
Detailed Overview
Color Swatch King: Variants
Reduce Variants Options Selection time with Variant Image Swatch, Color Swatch, Swatch on Collection
Key Features
- Variant Swatches: Color swatches, Custom image swatch, Variant image swatch
- Variant Picker: Show as Swatches, Buttons & Dropdowns with price, Label & Badges
- Variants on Collections Page: Add color or size swatches on collections page
- Bulk upload color swatches. Hide out of stock variants. Split Product Variants
- Works with Shopify Markets, B2B, Size charts, Filter & Search, Recommendations
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form
Collect product customization details with custom fields before checkout
Key Features
- 9 field types: Textfield, select, date picker, radio box, checkbox & more
- Form validations: Mandatory fields, minimum and maximum characters
- Display conditions: Display on selected product by product, vendor, type and tag
- Export order line properties to CSV or XLSX excel file
- Theme app extension: Customise your form to match your theme design
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Color Swatch King: Variants5/5 COLY ‑ Additional Order Form5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1959 | 2 |
Reviews Color Swatch King: Variants1959 COLY ‑ Additional Order Form2 | ||
| Primary Function | Variant selection enhancement & visual presentation | Collecting product customization details |
Primary Function Color Swatch King: VariantsVariant selection enhancement & visual presentation COLY ‑ Additional Order FormCollecting product customization details | ||
| Key Feature 1 | Color & Image Swatches | Custom Order Forms with various field types |
Key Feature 1 Color Swatch King: VariantsColor & Image Swatches COLY ‑ Additional Order FormCustom Order Forms with various field types | ||
| Key Feature 2 | Variants on Collection Page | Conditional Display of Form Fields |
Key Feature 2 Color Swatch King: VariantsVariants on Collection Page COLY ‑ Additional Order FormConditional Display of Form Fields | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants with numerous product variants and focus on visual appeal | Merchants selling personalized or customizable products |
Target Merchant Color Swatch King: VariantsMerchants with numerous product variants and focus on visual appeal COLY ‑ Additional Order FormMerchants selling personalized or customizable products | ||
| Ease of Use (Assumed) | Potentially easier to set up basic swatches, automation features | Potentially steeper learning curve due to form creation and conditional logic |
Ease of Use (Assumed) Color Swatch King: VariantsPotentially easier to set up basic swatches, automation features COLY ‑ Additional Order FormPotentially steeper learning curve due to form creation and conditional logic | ||
| Value Proposition | Increased conversion through better variant selection and product comparison | Facilitates personalized order management and gathering specific product specifications |
Value Proposition Color Swatch King: VariantsIncreased conversion through better variant selection and product comparison COLY ‑ Additional Order FormFacilitates personalized order management and gathering specific product specifications | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants selling products with many visually distinct variants (colors, patterns, etc.) and aiming to improve the customer's shopping experience and conversion rates, Color Swatch King is the superior choice. Its focus on visual representation and streamlined variant selection makes it a powerful tool for enhancing the user interface. The high number of positive reviews (1959) suggests widespread satisfaction and reliability.
However, if the primary need is to gather detailed product customization information from customers before they checkout, COLY - Additional Order Form is more appropriate. COLY’s functionality related to creating custom forms and validations are perfect for merchants selling personalized or made-to-order products. While it has a smaller number of reviews, its targeted feature set makes it ideal for its specific use case.
Common Questions
Which app is better for simply showing different colors of a shirt?
Color Swatch King is the better choice. Its core function is to present product variants, such as colors, in an attractive and user-friendly way using color swatches and image swatches.
Which app allows me to collect custom engraving text before a customer adds a product to their cart?
COLY ‑ Additional Order Form is specifically designed for this purpose. It lets you add custom fields to your product pages to gather personalization details like engraving text before the customer proceeds to checkout.
Does Color Swatch King support showing product pricing for different variants?
Yes, Color Swatch King allows you to show the price and labels associated with each variant option, facilitating quick decision-making for customers.
Can COLY automatically hide form fields based on the product selected?
Yes, COLY supports conditional display of form fields based on product properties like product, vendor, type, or tag, allowing you to create dynamic and context-aware forms.
Which app has better customer support?
Color Swatch King explicitly mentions 'Talk to our product variations experts for free app setup,' suggesting a higher level of support availability. COLY does not provide specific information on the availability of customer support resources within the app description.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store