Checkout Components | Upsell vs Shopy Payment Rulesfor Shopify (2026)
Checkout Components | Upsell and Shopy Payment Rules both aim to improve the checkout experience on Shopify, but target very different aspects. Checkout Components | Upsell focuses on increasing average order value through targeted upsells, cross-sells, and content blocks at checkout and post-purchase. It also supports advanced segmentation based on customer type, cart value, and location, along with custom fields for gathering additional information. This app integrates with popular review and personalization platforms. Shopy Payment Rules, on the other hand, provides tools to customize which payment methods are visible to specific customer types, particularly distinguishing between B2B and DTC customers. It enables merchants to rename, reorder, and prioritize payment options. While Checkout Components | Upsell is all about revenue optimization and broader checkout customization, Shopy Payment Rules concentrates on providing a more tailored and controlled payment selection process for different customer segments. The difference in focus makes them appeal to distinct merchant needs.
At a Glance
Checkout Components | Upsell
27 reviews
Shopy Payment Rules
1 reviews
Detailed Overview
Checkout Components | Upsell
Drive revenue with upsells at checkout and post-purchase. Customize with rules, blocks & fields.
Key Features
- Upsells & Cross-sells: One-click offers with product quick-view modals
- Segmentation & Rules: Target by customer type, cart value, or location
- Content Blocks: Banners, testimonials, trust badges, and custom messaging
- Custom Fields: Collect delivery notes, gift messages, and special instructions
- Integrates with Judge.me, Yotpo, Okendo, Algolia, Athos, Boost, Nosto & others
Shopy Payment Rules
With Codebeans Payment Rules, you can customize payment methods by customer type in just seconds.
Key Features
- Rename Payment Methods: Personalize labels to match your brand tone.
- Reorder Payment Methods: Arrange payment options as you prefer.
- Set Rules by Customer Type: Show methods by B2B or DTC type.
- Company-Specific Logic: Set custom payments for each company.
- Insert Missing Payment Method allows you to add overlooked or new payment option
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Checkout Components | Upsell5/5 Shopy Payment Rules5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 27 | 1 |
Reviews Checkout Components | Upsell27 Shopy Payment Rules1 | ||
| Focus | Upsells and Checkout Customization | Payment Method Customization |
Focus Checkout Components | UpsellUpsells and Checkout Customization Shopy Payment RulesPayment Method Customization | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants focused on AOV and conversions | Merchants selling to B2B and DTC customers |
Target Merchant Checkout Components | UpsellMerchants focused on AOV and conversions Shopy Payment RulesMerchants selling to B2B and DTC customers | ||
| Segmentation | Detailed: Customer, Cart Value, Location | Customer Type (B2B/DTC) |
Segmentation Checkout Components | UpsellDetailed: Customer, Cart Value, Location Shopy Payment RulesCustomer Type (B2B/DTC) | ||
| Integration | Judge.me, Yotpo, Okendo, Algolia, Athos, Boost, Nosto & others | Not Specified |
Integration Checkout Components | UpsellJudge.me, Yotpo, Okendo, Algolia, Athos, Boost, Nosto & others Shopy Payment RulesNot Specified | ||
| Checkout Customization | Content blocks, custom fields, trust badges, banners | Rename, reorder, and prioritize payment methods |
Checkout Customization Checkout Components | UpsellContent blocks, custom fields, trust badges, banners Shopy Payment RulesRename, reorder, and prioritize payment methods | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase average order value and conversion rates through upsells and targeted offers. | Tailor checkout experience for different customer types, improving payment selections. |
Value Proposition Checkout Components | UpsellIncrease average order value and conversion rates through upsells and targeted offers. Shopy Payment RulesTailor checkout experience for different customer types, improving payment selections. | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking to significantly boost their average order value through strategic upsells and cross-sells, coupled with comprehensive checkout customization options, Checkout Components | Upsell appears to be the stronger choice. Its wider range of features and integrations, along with a significantly higher number of reviews (suggesting broader usage and potential for community support), makes it an attractive option for stores prioritizing revenue optimization.
However, if a merchant's primary concern is controlling the payment options displayed to different customer segments (especially B2B vs. DTC), then Shopy Payment Rules directly addresses that need. While it has fewer reviews, its targeted focus on payment method management could prove valuable for merchants with specific requirements in that area, particularly where maintaining clear payment distinctions between customer types is essential.
Common Questions
Which app is better for increasing average order value (AOV)?
Checkout Components | Upsell is specifically designed to boost AOV through targeted upsells and cross-sells at checkout and post-purchase.
Can I use Shopy Payment Rules to add custom payment methods?
Shopy Payment Rules helps you to insert missing or new payment options, suggesting it supports adding previously overlooked payment methods.
Does Checkout Components | Upsell integrate with customer review platforms?
Yes, Checkout Components | Upsell integrates with Judge.me, Yotpo, and Okendo, among other platforms.
Is it easier to customize the checkout experience with Checkout Components | Upsell or Shopy Payment Rules?
Checkout Components | Upsell provides a more comprehensive approach to checkout customization, including content blocks, custom fields, trust badges, and banners, offering greater flexibility.
If I sell to both B2B and DTC customers, which app is more relevant?
Shopy Payment Rules is specifically designed for managing payment options for B2B and DTC customers.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store