CharityChoice Donations vs Impact By Salefor Shopify (2026)
CharityChoice Donations and Impact By Sale are both Shopify apps designed to integrate charitable giving into the e-commerce experience, but they cater to different approaches and merchant needs. CharityChoice Donations focuses on providing merchants with customizable donation widgets that allow customers to choose which charities to support, offering flexibility and a direct connection to specific causes. The emphasis is on customer choice and empowering them to direct their charitable contributions. Impact By Sale, on the other hand, takes a more automated approach, enabling merchants to tie specific sales to tangible environmental or social impacts, such as planting trees or removing ocean plastic. This option emphasizes guaranteed, measurable impact without requiring customers to select charities themselves.
At a Glance
CharityChoice Donations
1 reviews
Impact By Sale
5 reviews
Detailed Overview
CharityChoice Donations
Drive conversions and customer satisfaction with easy-to-set-up, custom donations.
Key Features
- Customisable Post-Purchase and storefront donation widgets
- Ability to donate to one or more charities
- Choose between store or customer donations.
- Donation order tagging and dashboard for tracking
- Fully customisable badges
Impact By Sale
Turn every sale into tangible impact with Impact By Sale. Positive impact made easy!
Key Features
- Create automatic, tangible, measurable impact with every sale using Impact Rules
- Micro-donate by: Portion of Sales, Customer Add-on, or Round Up
- Embed your 'Impact Ticker' on your site to display total impact in real-time
- Get automatic tax receipts
- Robust storytelling & donor feedback (videos, photos, stories)
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating CharityChoice Donations5/5 Impact By Sale5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1 | 5 |
Reviews CharityChoice Donations1 Impact By Sale5 | ||
| Donation Method | Customer-Directed Donations | Automatic Impact Per Sale |
Donation Method CharityChoice DonationsCustomer-Directed Donations Impact By SaleAutomatic Impact Per Sale | ||
| Customization | Fully Customizable Widgets & Badges | Impact Rules & Impact Ticker |
Customization CharityChoice DonationsFully Customizable Widgets & Badges Impact By SaleImpact Rules & Impact Ticker | ||
| Target Merchant | Non-profits, NGOs, and Small Businesses | Socially Conscious Businesses |
Target Merchant CharityChoice DonationsNon-profits, NGOs, and Small Businesses Impact By SaleSocially Conscious Businesses | ||
| Primary Benefit | Increased Customer Satisfaction & Trust through choice | Guaranteed & Measurable Positive Impact |
Primary Benefit CharityChoice DonationsIncreased Customer Satisfaction & Trust through choice Impact By SaleGuaranteed & Measurable Positive Impact | ||
| Impact Tracking | Donation Order Tagging and Dashboard | Impact Ticker, Automatic Tax Receipts, Robust Storytelling |
Impact Tracking CharityChoice DonationsDonation Order Tagging and Dashboard Impact By SaleImpact Ticker, Automatic Tax Receipts, Robust Storytelling | ||
| User Involvement | Customer chooses the charity/cause | Merchant preselects impact type based on sales. |
User Involvement CharityChoice DonationsCustomer chooses the charity/cause Impact By SaleMerchant preselects impact type based on sales. | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants seeking to empower their customers with choice and build trust through direct charitable donations, CharityChoice Donations is the better option. It provides flexible, customizable tools to integrate donation options throughout the shopping experience and allows customers to actively participate in the giving process. However, for businesses prioritizing automated, tangible, and measurable social or environmental impact with minimal customer involvement, Impact By Sale is more suitable. It offers a simpler, hands-off approach by linking sales to specific positive outcomes, providing evidence of impact and streamlining the donation process.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Both apps claim easy setup with no coding required, but Impact By Sale's automated approach suggests potentially simpler initial configuration as it relies on setting impact rules rather than designing custom donation widgets.
Which app provides more customer choice?
CharityChoice Donations gives customers the ability to choose which charities they want to support, while Impact By Sale automatically links sales to pre-determined impact projects.
Which app is better for a non-profit organization?
CharityChoice Donations might be more suitable for non-profits as it allows them to directly receive donations chosen by the customer and build donor relationships.
Which app is better for demonstrating impact to customers?
Impact By Sale provides robust storytelling and donor feedback, including videos, photos, and stories, to show customers the real-world impact of their purchases. CharityChoice Donations provides basic tracking and badges for your Shopify store.
Which app has a more established review base?
Impact By Sale has 5 reviews compared to CharityChoice Donations' single review, offering slightly more social proof (although the sample sizes remain small).
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store