Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery and Notifications by Modd Apps both aim to enhance the Shopify merchant's workflow but approach the problem from vastly different angles. Cartly focuses primarily on recovering abandoned carts and building email lists through automated email marketing, web push notifications, and on-site engagement tools like email pop-ups and a spin-to-win discount wheel. Its core value proposition is recovering lost revenue through direct, targeted communication with potential customers who have already shown interest in a purchase. Notifications by Modd Apps, on the other hand, provides a broader and more flexible solution for automating various tasks and communications based on specific store events. It emphasizes customizability and the ability to trigger actions (sending emails, updating tags, etc.) based on complex logic. Cartly's strength lies in its ease of use and pre-built automation workflows specifically tailored for abandoned cart recovery and basic email marketing. Notifications by Modd Apps excels in its power and flexibility, enabling merchants to create highly customized workflows for a wider range of purposes, including order management, customer segmentation, and vendor communication. However, this power comes at the cost of increased complexity. While both apps use web push capabilities, their primary focus diverges: Cartly uses it as a recovery tool, while Modd Apps does not provide specific use case within the details. The choice between the two depends heavily on the merchant's technical expertise and specific needs.
243 reviews
35 reviews
Abandoned cart recovery email automation & email popup to recover abandoned cart, abandoned checkout
Send custom emails, upload files, add tags and much more, trigger by any shop event!
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery4.9/5 Notifications by Modd Apps5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 243 | 35 |
Reviews Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery243 Notifications by Modd Apps35 | ||
| Primary Focus | Abandoned Cart Recovery & Email List Building | Customizable Event-Based Automation |
Primary Focus Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryAbandoned Cart Recovery & Email List Building Notifications by Modd AppsCustomizable Event-Based Automation | ||
| Target Audience | Merchants Seeking Simple, Out-of-the-Box Abandoned Cart Solution | Merchants with Complex Workflow Needs & Technical Proficiency |
Target Audience Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryMerchants Seeking Simple, Out-of-the-Box Abandoned Cart Solution Notifications by Modd AppsMerchants with Complex Workflow Needs & Technical Proficiency | ||
| Ease of Use | Generally Easier | More Complex, Requires Configuration |
Ease of Use Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryGenerally Easier Notifications by Modd AppsMore Complex, Requires Configuration | ||
| Key Features | Automated Email Sequences, Pop-Ups, Spin-a-Sale | Customizable Emails, Tagging, Liquid Support |
Key Features Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryAutomated Email Sequences, Pop-Ups, Spin-a-Sale Notifications by Modd AppsCustomizable Emails, Tagging, Liquid Support | ||
| Customization | Limited to Pre-Built Templates & Options | Highly Customizable with HTML & Liquid |
Customization Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryLimited to Pre-Built Templates & Options Notifications by Modd AppsHighly Customizable with HTML & Liquid | ||
| Value Proposition | Quick Revenue Recovery with Minimal Effort | Streamlined Operations & Enhanced Customer Experience Through Automation |
Value Proposition Cartly Abandoned Cart RecoveryQuick Revenue Recovery with Minimal Effort Notifications by Modd AppsStreamlined Operations & Enhanced Customer Experience Through Automation | ||
For merchants primarily concerned with recovering abandoned carts and growing their email list with minimal technical setup, Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery is likely the better choice. Its pre-built workflows and user-friendly interface make it easy to implement and start seeing results quickly. However, merchants with more complex needs beyond simple abandoned cart recovery – such as automating order management processes, segmenting customers based on specific criteria, or communicating with vendors – will find Notifications by Modd Apps to be a far more powerful and versatile solution. While it requires more technical expertise to configure, its ability to trigger actions based on specific events and use complex logic provides a level of customization that Cartly simply cannot match. Therefore, merchants comfortable with code or willing to invest the time to learn should opt for Modd Apps' Notifications, otherwise Cartly is better suited.
Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery is generally easier to set up and use due to its pre-built workflows and user-friendly interface. Notifications by Modd Apps requires more configuration and technical knowledge.
Yes, both apps can send emails. Cartly focuses on abandoned cart recovery and order follow-up emails, while Notifications by Modd Apps allows for sending custom emails based on any store event.
Notifications by Modd Apps is significantly better for customizing emails, offering extensive control with HTML and Liquid. Cartly's email customization is limited to its pre-built templates.
Notifications by Modd Apps is better for advanced automation. It allows merchants to create complex workflows based on specific conditions and trigger actions like tagging customers or sending files.
Cartly Abandoned Cart Recovery is explicitly focused on revenue recovery through abandoned cart recovery emails, email pop-ups, and discount offers. Notifications by Modd Apps can indirectly contribute to revenue recovery by improving customer experience and streamlining operations, but this is not its primary focus.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store