Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees vs UpCharge Fees Addons Surchargefor Shopify (2026)
Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees and UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge are Shopify apps designed to help merchants automate and manage fees, surcharges, and deposits. Canteen positions itself as a specialized solution primarily for businesses needing to manage complex deposit and fee rules, especially those related to container deposits (like Pfand, CRV, and similar regional deposit systems). It emphasizes automation and flexible rule sets, including detailed options and POS support. UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge, on the other hand, offers a more general-purpose solution for adding various types of fees, surcharges, and tariffs to orders. It provides location-based fees and the ability to attach fees to specific products or the entire cart, appealing to a broader range of businesses looking for more general fee management.
At a Glance
Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees
47 reviews
UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge
108 reviews
Detailed Overview
Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees
Canteen makes deposit and fee rules easy, from bottle, can, CRV, Pfand, Pant—collect missing fees.
Key Features
- Automate bottle, can, keg, and container deposits including Pfand and CRV fees
- Add service, handling, processing fees, surcharges, and security deposits easily
- Create flexible fee rules with one-time, per-cart, or per-item configurations
- Customize fee names, thumbnails, tax behavior, and checkout visibility options
- Works seamlessly across Shopify Online Store and Shopify POS with full support
UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge
Add fees, surcharges & tariffs to orders. Charge additional fees for handling, add-ons, or services.
Key Features
- Unlimited product fees, surcharges and tariffs
- Location-based order fees, tariffs & surcharges
- Fixed-amount fees & percentage fees based on product price or order subtotal
- Settings and conditions that control when certain fees are applied or triggered
- Payment & shipping method-based fees (Shopify Plus only)
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.6/5 | 4.4/5 |
Rating Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees4.6/5 UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge4.4/5 | ||
| Reviews | 47 | 108 |
Reviews Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees47 UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge108 | ||
| Focus | Specialized: Deposit and Fee Automation (e.g., container deposits) | General: Broad range of fees, surcharges & tariffs |
Focus Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesSpecialized: Deposit and Fee Automation (e.g., container deposits) UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeGeneral: Broad range of fees, surcharges & tariffs | ||
| Shopify POS Support | Full Support | Not explicitly mentioned |
Shopify POS Support Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesFull Support UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeNot explicitly mentioned | ||
| Location-Based Fees | Not explicitly mentioned | Yes |
Location-Based Fees Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesNot explicitly mentioned UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeYes | ||
| Payment/Shipping Method-Based Fees | Not explicitly mentioned | Yes (Shopify Plus only) |
Payment/Shipping Method-Based Fees Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesNot explicitly mentioned UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeYes (Shopify Plus only) | ||
| Target Merchant | Businesses handling container deposits, recycling fees, core charges | Businesses needing general fee/surcharge management with location based options |
Target Merchant Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesBusinesses handling container deposits, recycling fees, core charges UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeBusinesses needing general fee/surcharge management with location based options | ||
| Tax Control | Yes | Implied, but not explicitly highlighted |
Tax Control Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesYes UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeImplied, but not explicitly highlighted | ||
| Fee Granularity | One-time, per-cart, or per-item | Fixed-amount or percentage based on product or subtotal |
Fee Granularity Canteen ‑ Deposits and FeesOne-time, per-cart, or per-item UpCharge Fees Addons SurchargeFixed-amount or percentage based on product or subtotal | ||
Our Verdict
If your business heavily relies on managing container deposits (like Pfand, CRV, etc.) and requires sophisticated automation with POS support, Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees appears to be the stronger choice. It's built specifically for this purpose and has a slightly higher rating. However, if you need a more general-purpose solution for adding various types of fees and surcharges, particularly if location-based fees or Shopify Plus payment/shipping method fees are important, UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge is the better option. The higher number of reviews on UpCharge suggests a wider user base and potentially more diverse application scenarios. Canteen excels in a niche, while UpCharge provides broader functionality.
Common Questions
Which app is better for handling bottle deposit fees in Germany (Pfand)?
Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees is specifically designed for handling deposits like Pfand, CRV, Pant, etc., making it the likely better choice for this scenario. UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge mentions bottle deposits, but does not focus on this niche as much as Canteen does.
Does either app allow me to charge a fee based on the customer's location?
UpCharge Fees Addons Surcharge explicitly supports location-based order fees, tariffs, and surcharges. Canteen ‑ Deposits and Fees does not explicitly mention this feature.
Which app is easier to set up and use?
While hard to say definitively, Canteen's focus on a specific type of fee structure (deposits) might make it easier to set up for that particular use case. However, without user reviews comparing ease of use, it's impossible to know for sure. UpCharge’s generality might make it less intuitive.
Can I use these apps to charge a 'convenience fee' for online orders?
Both apps mention the ability to add convenience fees. Canteen explicitly lists 'convenience fees' as a feature, while UpCharge mentions fees for special handling or processing, which could include a convenience fee.
Which app is better for a high-volume online store with a complex product catalog?
Both apps offer features suitable for stores with complex catalogs. UpCharge's unlimited product fees might be beneficial for a very large product catalog. Canteen offers granular controls for applying fees per item, per cart, or one-time, which could be helpful for complex fee structures associated with specific products.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store