BuyAfterTry vs Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypherfor Shopify (2026)
BuyAfterTry and Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher both fall under the 'Payment options - Other' category on Shopify, but cater to very different needs and merchants. BuyAfterTry focuses on a 'try before you buy' experience, offering multiple selling plans and easy returns. It's aimed at merchants who want to reduce purchase anxiety and increase customer engagement by allowing potential buyers to experience the product before committing to a full purchase. Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher, on the other hand, provides flexible payment options like partial payments, deferred payments, and installment plans (NET30, Pre-Order) with card on file. It targets merchants selling high-value or made-to-order products where customers might require more financial flexibility. The crucial difference lies in their core functionalities. BuyAfterTry prioritizes product access and experiential selling, aiming to boost conversion through familiarity. Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher, focuses on payment flexibility, striving to increase sales by removing financial barriers. The former is about trust and product experience, while the latter is about affordability and payment convenience. One is more about mitigating risk of returns by showcasing value, the other is about making purchases accessible to a wider range of customers. The significant disparity in ratings and review counts is also a major factor. Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher has 5/5 rating and 7 reviews, suggesting existing users are satisfied, while BuyAfterTry lacks reviews. This lack of user feedback makes it difficult to assess BuyAfterTry's reliability and effectiveness.
At a Glance
BuyAfterTry
0 reviews
Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher
7 reviews
Detailed Overview
BuyAfterTry
App offers purchase options like "BuyAfterTry", multiple selling plans & returns
Key Features
- Allow customers to try before they buy.
- Ability to create multiple selling plans for each product
- Easy Returns interface for customers.
Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher
Partial, Split, Deposits, Pay Later, NET30, Pre Order pay options with card on file. COD Supported
Key Features
- Deferred, Partial, Split, Deposits, Pay Later, COD or NET30 payment options
- Payment options on Product (Deposit on Products) or cart page (Deposit on total)
- Charge customer their balance on their card before shipping or on due date
- One click setup. Can be managed from theme customize. Support all languages
- Streamline COD Orders with our app and Minimize Your RTO!
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 0/5 | 5/5 |
Rating BuyAfterTry0/5 Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 0 | 7 |
Reviews BuyAfterTry0 Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher7 | ||
| Core Functionality | Try Before Buy & Multiple Selling Plans | Flexible Payment Options (Split Pay, Pay Later) |
Core Functionality BuyAfterTryTry Before Buy & Multiple Selling Plans Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherFlexible Payment Options (Split Pay, Pay Later) | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants wanting to offer a 'Try Before Buy' experience | Merchants selling high-value or made-to-order products |
Target Merchant Type BuyAfterTryMerchants wanting to offer a 'Try Before Buy' experience Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherMerchants selling high-value or made-to-order products | ||
| Key Differentiator | Focus on product experience and reducing purchase anxiety. | Focus on payment flexibility and affordability. |
Key Differentiator BuyAfterTryFocus on product experience and reducing purchase anxiety. Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherFocus on payment flexibility and affordability. | ||
| Returns Management | Easy Returns Interface | Not explicitly mentioned |
Returns Management BuyAfterTryEasy Returns Interface Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherNot explicitly mentioned | ||
| Ease of Use | Very Easy to Use Interface Claimed | One-click Setup |
Ease of Use BuyAfterTryVery Easy to Use Interface Claimed Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherOne-click Setup | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase revenues by allowing customers to experience products before committing. | Increase AOV and drive more sales by offering flexible payment options. |
Value Proposition BuyAfterTryIncrease revenues by allowing customers to experience products before committing. Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ CypherIncrease AOV and drive more sales by offering flexible payment options. | ||
Our Verdict
Based on the information available, Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher appears to be the more established and reliable option for merchants seeking to offer flexible payment options. The positive reviews provide some assurance of its functionality and customer satisfaction. It is a solid option for high value items where customers require options to split their payments.
BuyAfterTry might be a better fit for merchants who prioritize offering a 'Try Before Buy' experience, but the lack of reviews makes it difficult to assess its effectiveness and reliability. If the idea of BuyAfterTry suits your store, it would require careful consideration and possibly direct communication with the app developers to understand its capabilities better and assess its suitability for your specific needs. Because of the lack of user reviews and overall rating, Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher is the stronger recommendation at this point in time.
Common Questions
Which app is better for increasing Average Order Value (AOV)?
Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher explicitly claims to increase AOV by offering deposit options and encouraging purchases through flexible payment plans. While BuyAfterTry aims to increase revenue generally, it doesn't directly mention AOV impact.
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Both apps claim to be easy to use. BuyAfterTry claims a 'very intuitive interface,' while Pay Later, Split Pay ‑ Cypher mentions a 'one-click setup.' The lack of reviews for BuyAfterTry makes it difficult to verify its ease of use compared to Pay Later, Split Pay - Cypher.
Which app better supports businesses selling physical products?
Both apps are suitable for physical products. However, Pay Later, Split Pay - Cypher is particularly well-suited for higher value or made to order products, making these more accessible to potential buyers through payment plans.
How do returns work with Pay Later, Split Pay - Cypher?
The description for Pay Later, Split Pay - Cypher doesn't provide information about returns management. However, since it supports partial payments, any refund amounts are limited to what was collected.
What if I want to offer both payment plans and try before you buy options?
It might be possible to integrate both apps or use them separately for different products or customer segments. However, potential conflicts or compatibility issues should be investigated. Another option is to consider a single app that includes both capabilities if it exists.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store