BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty vs Smart Wishlistfor Shopify (2026)
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty and Smart Wishlist both aim to enhance customer retention on Shopify stores, but they approach it with very different functionalities. BLOY focuses on building comprehensive loyalty programs with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referral programs, targeting merchants who want to implement a robust and feature-rich loyalty system. Smart Wishlist, on the other hand, simplifies the shopping experience by allowing customers to create and share wishlists easily, even without logging in, which primarily caters to merchants seeking a straightforward way to convert window shoppers and reduce purchase friction. The core difference lies in the depth and complexity of their features; BLOY offers a full-fledged loyalty solution, while Smart Wishlist provides a streamlined wishlist functionality.
At a Glance
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty
267 reviews
Smart Wishlist
81 reviews
Detailed Overview
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty
Build a loyalty program to increase retention with points, rewards, VIP tiers, membership and POS.
Key Features
- Build and scale a customer loyalty program with points, rewards, and VIP tiers
- Reward purchases and actions with loyalty points customers actually redeem
- Design VIP tiers and memberships to drive higher repeat purchase behavior
- Activate referral rewards to grow retention-led customer acquisition
- Launch and optimize your loyalty program with confidence and 24/7 support
Smart Wishlist
Increase customer retention, drive sales. No coding required.
Key Features
- Wishlist button on product, collection, search result and cart pages
- Both Guests & logged-in users can quickly create and share wishlists
- Unlimited wishlists across all stores. No strings attached
- Javascript and REST APIs to meet advanced requirements
- Lightweight Payload. Doesn't break your theme upon uninstall
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 5/5 | 3.6/5 |
Rating BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty5/5 Smart Wishlist3.6/5 | ||
| Reviews | 267 | 81 |
Reviews BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty267 Smart Wishlist81 | ||
| Core Functionality | Comprehensive Loyalty Program (Points, Rewards, VIP Tiers) | Simple Wishlist Functionality (One-Click Saving) |
Core Functionality BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyComprehensive Loyalty Program (Points, Rewards, VIP Tiers) Smart WishlistSimple Wishlist Functionality (One-Click Saving) | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants seeking a robust, feature-rich loyalty program | Merchants seeking a simple and easy-to-implement wishlist solution |
Target Merchant BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyMerchants seeking a robust, feature-rich loyalty program Smart WishlistMerchants seeking a simple and easy-to-implement wishlist solution | ||
| Ease of Use | Potentially more complex setup due to the number of features; 24/7 support offered | Super-easy setup with no coding required |
Ease of Use BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyPotentially more complex setup due to the number of features; 24/7 support offered Smart WishlistSuper-easy setup with no coding required | ||
| Customer Account Requirement | Encourages account creation for loyalty program benefits | Allows wishlist creation without logging in |
Customer Account Requirement BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyEncourages account creation for loyalty program benefits Smart WishlistAllows wishlist creation without logging in | ||
| Integration with POS | Yes, mentioned in headline | Not mentioned |
Integration with POS BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyYes, mentioned in headline Smart WishlistNot mentioned | ||
| Pricing (inferred) | Likely tiered pricing reflecting feature depth | Likely simpler pricing, potentially free plan |
Pricing (inferred) BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyLikely tiered pricing reflecting feature depth Smart WishlistLikely simpler pricing, potentially free plan | ||
Our Verdict
If you're looking to build a deep, engaging loyalty program with various tiers, rewards, and points, BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty is the clear choice. Its robust feature set and 24/7 support make it ideal for businesses committed to building long-term customer relationships through a comprehensive loyalty strategy. However, if you prioritize ease of use and want a simple way to allow customers to save and share items they're interested in, Smart Wishlist is the better option. It's perfect for merchants who want a quick win without the complexity of a full loyalty program and particularly useful for stores where encouraging guest wishlists could drive sales.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up and use?
Smart Wishlist is likely easier to set up and use due to its focus on simplicity and the claim that no coding is required. BLOY, with its extensive features, might require more configuration.
Which app is better for building a long-term loyalty program?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty is designed specifically for building a long-term loyalty program with points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referral rewards. Smart Wishlist primarily focuses on capturing initial interest and converting window shoppers.
Which app is better for stores that have both online and offline sales?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty, with its mention of POS integration in the headline, is better suited for stores that operate both online and offline.
Is customer account creation required for either app?
While not explicitly stated, BLOY likely encourages account creation to track loyalty points and manage rewards. Smart Wishlist allows customers to create wishlists even without logging in, offering greater flexibility.
Which app has better customer support?
BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty specifically mentions 24/7 support, suggesting a stronger focus on customer assistance. Smart Wishlist does not mention support in its description.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store