Basic Wishlist vs E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewardsfor Shopify (2026)
In 2026, Basic Wishlist and E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards cater to different aspects of customer interaction and retention on Shopify. Basic Wishlist focuses on improving the shopping experience by enabling customers to save desired products for later purchase. It aims to increase conversions through a streamlined wishlist feature including a product page button, fixed sidebar, and popup. It's positioned as a simple tool to enhance convenience and drive sales through product saving. E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards, on the other hand, targets long-term customer engagement and loyalty. It offers a comprehensive suite of features, including points-based loyalty programs, referral programs, and VIP tiers. It’s designed to turn first-time buyers into loyal customers through rewards, gamification, and personalized perks. The key difference lies in scope: Basic Wishlist focuses on short-term conversion through wishlists, while E! builds customer retention through rewards and loyalty programs.
At a Glance
Basic Wishlist
3 reviews
E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards
275 reviews
Detailed Overview
Basic Wishlist
Discover, Save & Shop. Increase the conversion rate at your store with the add to wishlist button.
Key Features
- Add to wishlist button at product page
- Fixed sidebar with product counter
- Product list popup
E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards
Create a fun, customizable loyalty and rewards program with points, referrals program, VIP tiers
Key Features
- Loyalty program with points, rewards program, referrals, and VIP tiers.
- Loyalty and Rewards program: offer points, discounts, or exclusive perks.
- Referral Program: Refer a friend with referral link. Refer and earn discounts!
- VIP rewards program: offer exclusive perks with VIP tiers & loyalty rewards!
- Friendly 24/7 support, multi language translation & smart tracking / analytics
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 2.7/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Basic Wishlist2.7/5 E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 3 | 275 |
Reviews Basic Wishlist3 E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards275 | ||
| Core Functionality | Wishlist Functionality | Loyalty and Rewards Program |
Core Functionality Basic WishlistWishlist Functionality E! ‑ Loyalty Program & RewardsLoyalty and Rewards Program | ||
| Key Features | Wishlist button, sidebar, popup | Points, referrals, VIP tiers, rewards |
Key Features Basic WishlistWishlist button, sidebar, popup E! ‑ Loyalty Program & RewardsPoints, referrals, VIP tiers, rewards | ||
| Target Merchant | Merchants wanting to reduce cart abandonment | Merchants focused on long-term customer retention |
Target Merchant Basic WishlistMerchants wanting to reduce cart abandonment E! ‑ Loyalty Program & RewardsMerchants focused on long-term customer retention | ||
| Ease of Use (implied) | Likely simple due to limited features | Potentially more complex due to numerous features, but likely well-supported |
Ease of Use (implied) Basic WishlistLikely simple due to limited features E! ‑ Loyalty Program & RewardsPotentially more complex due to numerous features, but likely well-supported | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase conversions through convenient product saving | Boost sales and build customer loyalty with rewards and gamification |
Value Proposition Basic WishlistIncrease conversions through convenient product saving E! ‑ Loyalty Program & RewardsBoost sales and build customer loyalty with rewards and gamification | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily concerned with improving immediate conversions and reducing cart abandonment by allowing customers to easily save products for later, Basic Wishlist might seem appealing, if they can deal with the very low rating and lack of reviews. However, E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards is the better choice for merchants who want to build a long-term, engaged customer base. The significantly higher rating and large number of positive reviews indicate that E! is a more reliable and effective app. While more complex, E!'s comprehensive feature set and strong support make it a superior investment for fostering customer loyalty.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to set up?
Based on the features listed, Basic Wishlist is likely easier to set up due to its simpler functionality. E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards involves configuring points, referrals, and VIP tiers, potentially requiring more setup time.
Which app provides more customer support?
E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards explicitly mentions 'Friendly 24/7 support,' suggesting a more robust support system than Basic Wishlist, which does not mention support in its description.
Which app is more scalable for a growing business?
E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards is more scalable due to its comprehensive loyalty and rewards features. It allows for building deeper customer relationships as the business grows, while Basic Wishlist's functionality remains static.
Which app is better for a new Shopify store?
A new Shopify store focusing on acquiring first customers might consider Basic Wishlist for its simplicity if they need a wishlist feature, but the very low rating is concerning. However, investing in E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards early on can build a solid foundation for customer loyalty from the start.
How do these apps impact customer lifetime value (CLTV)?
Basic Wishlist might indirectly increase CLTV by making it easier for customers to purchase saved items. E! ‑ Loyalty Program & Rewards is designed to directly improve CLTV by incentivizing repeat purchases and fostering long-term loyalty through rewards and VIP benefits.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store