Basic Wishlist and BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty, while both categorized under 'Customer loyalty' on Shopify, address fundamentally different aspects of customer engagement. Basic Wishlist focuses on facilitating product saving and purchase at a later time by offering a simple wishlist functionality. Its core strength lies in its direct approach to reducing cart abandonment by providing an easy way for customers to bookmark items they are interested in. The target audience for Basic Wishlist is smaller merchants looking for a lightweight solution to encourage repeat visits and eventual purchases. BLOYY Rewards Program & Loyalty, in contrast, offers a comprehensive loyalty program management system. It aims to build long-term customer relationships by rewarding purchases, actions, and engagement with points, VIP tiers, and referral rewards. Its strength is its ability to foster customer retention and increase lifetime value through a structured reward system. The target audience for BLOY is merchants looking to implement a robust loyalty program to drive repeat purchases and grow their customer base actively. It’s a more complex and feature-rich solution than Basic Wishlist, requiring more setup and management but offering potentially greater rewards.
3 reviews
267 reviews
Discover, Save & Shop. Increase the conversion rate at your store with the add to wishlist button.
Build a loyalty program to increase retention with points, rewards, VIP tiers, membership and POS.
| Rating | 2.7/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Basic Wishlist2.7/5 BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 3 | 267 |
Reviews Basic Wishlist3 BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty267 | ||
| Core Functionality | Wishlist Management | Loyalty Program Management |
Core Functionality Basic WishlistWishlist Management BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyLoyalty Program Management | ||
| Target Merchant | Small businesses seeking simple wishlist feature | Businesses wanting to build comprehensive loyalty program |
Target Merchant Basic WishlistSmall businesses seeking simple wishlist feature BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyBusinesses wanting to build comprehensive loyalty program | ||
| Key Features | Add to Wishlist button, Sidebar counter, Product popup | Points, Rewards, VIP Tiers, Referral Rewards, 24/7 Support |
Key Features Basic WishlistAdd to Wishlist button, Sidebar counter, Product popup BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyPoints, Rewards, VIP Tiers, Referral Rewards, 24/7 Support | ||
| Ease of Use | Likely simple setup given limited features | Potentially more complex setup and ongoing management |
Ease of Use Basic WishlistLikely simple setup given limited features BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyPotentially more complex setup and ongoing management | ||
| Value Proposition | Increase conversion by saving products for later | Increase customer retention and lifetime value through rewards |
Value Proposition Basic WishlistIncrease conversion by saving products for later BLOY Rewards Program & LoyaltyIncrease customer retention and lifetime value through rewards | ||
| Customer Support | Not explicitly mentioned in description | 24/7 support for modern Shopify stores |
Customer Support Basic WishlistNot explicitly mentioned in description BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty24/7 support for modern Shopify stores | ||
For merchants seeking a simple, lightweight solution to allow customers to save products for later, Basic Wishlist might be an initial choice. However, the low rating and extremely limited number of reviews are concerning. Merchants should thoroughly investigate before committing. BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty, on the other hand, is clearly the superior choice for merchants serious about building a loyalty program and driving customer retention. The high rating and large number of positive reviews indicate a reliable and effective app. While it requires more effort to set up and manage, the potential return on investment is significantly higher. It's a clear recommendation for merchants prioritizing long-term customer relationships.
Given the stark differences in ratings and features, BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty is the generally recommended choice, unless a merchant specifically needs *only* a basic wishlist function and is willing to gamble on an unproven app with a low rating. Even then, exploring alternative, better-reviewed wishlist apps would be prudent.
Basic Wishlist focuses solely on allowing customers to save products to a wishlist, while BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty offers a full-fledged loyalty program with points, rewards, and VIP tiers.
Basic Wishlist is likely easier to set up due to its limited feature set. BLOY Rewards Program & Loyalty will likely require more configuration to customize the loyalty program to specific business needs.
BLOYY Rewards Program & Loyalty is specifically designed to increase customer retention through its loyalty program features. Basic Wishlist may indirectly contribute to retention by allowing customers to easily return to products they were interested in.
BLOYY Rewards Program & Loyalty explicitly mentions 24/7 support, while Basic Wishlist does not mention any specific support features. Therefore, BLOY is more likely to provide better customer support.
For a brand new Shopify store, BLOY may be the stronger choice given its robust loyalty program and better rating, offering the potential to build loyalty from the start. However, if budget is extremely tight and only a basic wishlist is needed, and there's time to monitor closely, Basic Wishlist *might* be considered, but cautiously and with thorough pre-purchase research.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store