Avis Product Options, Variants and Magical Custom Fields & Upload both aim to enhance product customization on Shopify. Avis Product Options, Variants, judging by its high rating and significantly larger number of reviews (1366 vs 61), appears to be a more established and widely adopted solution for standard product variant creation and management. Magical Custom Fields & Upload, on the other hand, while also highly rated, focuses on advanced customization through custom fields, file uploads, and order personalization, targeting merchants needing more than basic product options and aiming for deeper customer interaction and customized order processing. It also caters specifically to Shopify Plus merchants with checkout custom fields functionality. Magical Custom Fields & Upload differentiates itself by offering features like file uploads, text boxes, checkboxes, dropdowns, and date pickers, enabling merchants to collect personalized order details and gift messages. Avis Product Options, Variants focuses primarily on adding and managing different product variants. The availability of upsell features and rule-based field application in Magical Custom Fields & Upload provides a clear distinction in terms of advanced marketing capabilities and precise field targeting. While both apps fall under the 'Custom products' and 'Product variants' Shopify categories, their implementations and target users are subtly different.
1,366 reviews
61 reviews
Easily add product options, checkout custom fields (Plus), file upload, upsells and more to orders.
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Avis Product Options, Variants5/5 Magical Custom Fields & Upload5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 1366 | 61 |
Reviews Avis Product Options, Variants1366 Magical Custom Fields & Upload61 | ||
| Core Functionality | Product Variant Creation/Management | Custom Fields, File Uploads, Order Personalization |
Core Functionality Avis Product Options, VariantsProduct Variant Creation/Management Magical Custom Fields & UploadCustom Fields, File Uploads, Order Personalization | ||
| Shopify Plus Support | Unknown | Checkout Custom Fields |
Shopify Plus Support Avis Product Options, VariantsUnknown Magical Custom Fields & UploadCheckout Custom Fields | ||
| Upselling Capabilities | No Information | Fixed or Percentage-Based Upsells |
Upselling Capabilities Avis Product Options, VariantsNo Information Magical Custom Fields & UploadFixed or Percentage-Based Upsells | ||
| Flexibility | Likely basic variant rules | Flexible rules and conditional logic for field application |
Flexibility Avis Product Options, VariantsLikely basic variant rules Magical Custom Fields & UploadFlexible rules and conditional logic for field application | ||
| Target Merchant | General Shopify merchants needing product variants | Merchants needing advanced order customization and personalization, especially Shopify Plus users |
Target Merchant Avis Product Options, VariantsGeneral Shopify merchants needing product variants Magical Custom Fields & UploadMerchants needing advanced order customization and personalization, especially Shopify Plus users | ||
| Value Proposition | Efficiently manage product variations | Enhance order personalization, collect customer details, and boost sales through custom fields and upsells |
Value Proposition Avis Product Options, VariantsEfficiently manage product variations Magical Custom Fields & UploadEnhance order personalization, collect customer details, and boost sales through custom fields and upsells | ||
If you primarily need to create and manage different product variations (size, color, etc.), Avis Product Options, Variants, given its larger user base reflected in the number of reviews, appears to be a safe and reliable choice. However, if your business model revolves around highly personalized products, requires file uploads, or you want to offer upsells based on specific custom options, and you may even be a Shopify Plus merchant needing checkout customization, then Magical Custom Fields & Upload is the superior option. The feature set of Magical Custom Fields & Upload clearly caters to a more specific and advanced customization requirement than the likely broader capabilities of Avis Product Options, Variants.
Avis Product Options, Variants is likely the better choice for standard size and color options, based on its larger adoption and focus on variant management.
Magical Custom Fields & Upload explicitly offers file upload functionality, which Avis Product Options, Variants does not mention.
Magical Custom Fields & Upload appears more suited for this, as it emphasizes order personalization and offers text box custom fields. Avis Product Options, Variants may offer text-based variants, but it's not its core strength.
Magical Custom Fields & Upload offers specific support for checkout custom fields for Shopify Plus merchants, while Avis Product Options, Variants does not mention this feature.
Given its widespread adoption, Avis Product Options, Variants is likely a more suitable choice for basic product options and managing standard variations, offering potentially simpler integration and use.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store