1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups vs Toastibar Sales Popup & Timersfor Shopify (2026)
1Click Popups and Toastibar offer distinct approaches to boosting Shopify store performance via notifications and pop-ups. 1Click Popups focuses primarily on list building through email and SMS, utilizing features like customizable pop-ups, embedded forms, spin wheels, and discount offers. Its strength lies in capturing leads for marketing campaigns and integrating with popular email marketing platforms. A key differentiator is its lead capture powered by Shop, leveraging Shop's user base for faster checkout experiences. Toastibar, on the other hand, emphasizes driving sales through social proof and urgency. It displays real-time sales, cart activity, visitor counts, and reviews, coupled with countdown timers, aiming to convert visitors into buyers. Toastibar's features are geared toward creating a sense of FOMO (fear of missing out) and trust, utilizing geo-location and multilingual support to personalize the experience globally. While 1Click Popups aims to acquire leads for long-term marketing, Toastibar prioritizes immediate sales conversion by showcasing recent customer activity. The app's built-in analytics allows for tracking performance and optimization of pop-up engagement. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on whether the merchant's primary goal is list building or immediate sales uplift.
At a Glance
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
223 reviews
Toastibar Sales Popup & Timers
537 reviews
Detailed Overview
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
Grow your email & SMS list with email popups, embedded forms, spin wheel, and discount pop ups.
Key Features
- Build popups, forms, and announcements with a visual editor
- Capture sign ups with email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels
- Collect leads from Shop’s 100M+ users for faster checkout
- Generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout
- Sync to Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp & enable double opt-in
Toastibar Sales Popup & Timers
Elevate Sales with FOMO & Social Proof: Sales,Cart,Visitor,Review,Summary Popups & Countdown Timers
Key Features
- Valentine's Day sale popups & urgency countdown timers
- Show real-time sales, cart, visitor & review popups with countdown timers
- Geo-location & multilingual support: display popups in 75+ languages globally
- Track clicks, impressions & CTR with built-in analytics to optimize conversions
- Drive urgency with countdown timers on product, cart, landing & top/bottom bars
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.9/5 |
Rating 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups4.9/5 Toastibar Sales Popup & Timers4.9/5 | ||
| Reviews | 223 | 537 |
Reviews 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups223 Toastibar Sales Popup & Timers537 | ||
| Primary Focus | Email & SMS List Building | Sales Conversion via Social Proof & Urgency |
Primary Focus 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsEmail & SMS List Building Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersSales Conversion via Social Proof & Urgency | ||
| Key Features | Email Popups, Spin Wheel, Discount Popups, Shop Lead Capture | Sales Popups, Add-to-Cart Popups, Visitor Count, Countdown Timers, Multilingual Support |
Key Features 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsEmail Popups, Spin Wheel, Discount Popups, Shop Lead Capture Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersSales Popups, Add-to-Cart Popups, Visitor Count, Countdown Timers, Multilingual Support | ||
| Integration | Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp | Built-in Analytics |
Integration 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsShopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersBuilt-in Analytics | ||
| Target Merchant Type | Merchants focused on growing email and SMS lists for marketing campaigns | Merchants focused on driving immediate sales through social proof and urgency tactics |
Target Merchant Type 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsMerchants focused on growing email and SMS lists for marketing campaigns Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersMerchants focused on driving immediate sales through social proof and urgency tactics | ||
| Ease of Use | Visual Editor for Popup Design | Customizable Templates |
Ease of Use 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor for Popup Design Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersCustomizable Templates | ||
| Value Proposition | Grow audience and drive repeat purchases through email and SMS | Increase conversion rate and average order value through social proof and urgency |
Value Proposition 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsGrow audience and drive repeat purchases through email and SMS Toastibar Sales Popup & TimersIncrease conversion rate and average order value through social proof and urgency | ||
- Conversion Audit
- Speed Audit
- SEO Audit
Conversion Audit
Our Verdict
For merchants prioritizing growing their email and SMS lists for long-term marketing efforts, 1Click Popups is the better choice. Its integration with email marketing platforms and unique lead capture through Shop provide a valuable advantage. For those focused on immediately boosting sales by creating a sense of urgency and leveraging social proof, Toastibar is the stronger option. Its real-time sales popups, countdown timers, and multilingual support are specifically designed to drive conversions at the point of sale. While both apps have excellent ratings, Toastibar's higher number of reviews suggests a larger user base and potentially more extensive feedback to draw upon.
Common Questions
Which app is better for generating discount codes?
1Click Popups can generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout. Toastibar does not explicitly mention discount code generation.
Which app offers multilingual support?
Toastibar offers geo-location and multilingual support, displaying popups in 75+ languages. 1Click Popups does not explicitly mention multilingual support.
Which app focuses more on email marketing?
1Click Popups focuses heavily on email marketing, offering integrations with Shopify Email, Klaviyo, and Mailchimp for syncing subscribers and enabling double opt-in. Toastibar does not have these direct email marketing integrations.
Which app is better for tracking performance?
Toastibar includes built-in analytics to track clicks, impressions, and CTR. 1Click Popups doesn't specify built-in analytics; tracking would likely be handled through integrated email marketing platforms or Shopify's analytics.
Does either app utilize A/B testing?
Toastibar mentions leveraging A/B testing for maximum ROI. A/B testing is not mentioned for 1Click Popups based on the information provided.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store