1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups vs Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popupfor Shopify (2026)
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups and Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup, while both utilizing pop-ups, serve distinct purposes and cater to different growth strategies for Shopify merchants. 1Click Popups focuses on email and SMS list building through various opt-in methods like email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels. A major differentiator is its integration with Shop, allowing merchants to capture leads from Shop's vast user base. It also heavily emphasizes integrations with email marketing platforms like Klaviyo and Mailchimp. Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup, on the other hand, centers around social proof and FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) through sales notifications. It aims to boost conversions by displaying recent sales activity and add-to-cart events. It offers a highly customizable design and emphasizes ease of use with its theme integration and analytics tracking. The choice between the two hinges on whether the merchant prioritizes list building and email marketing (1Click Popups) or leveraging social proof to drive immediate sales (Proof Bear).
At a Glance
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
223 reviews
Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup
110 reviews
Detailed Overview
1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups
Grow your email & SMS list with email popups, embedded forms, spin wheel, and discount pop ups.
Key Features
- Build popups, forms, and announcements with a visual editor
- Capture sign ups with email popups, discount pop ups, and spin wheels
- Collect leads from Shop’s 100M+ users for faster checkout
- Generate unique discount codes and auto-apply them at checkout
- Sync to Shopify Email, Klaviyo, Mailchimp & enable double opt-in
Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup
Boost sales & increase trust by providing your customers with social proof of recent sales pop ups.
Key Features
- Sales pop up and add-to-cart pop up notifications to create fast social proof.
- Complete design control of sales popup color & text to match your store & brand.
- Use analytics to track every sales popup click to better understand your buyers.
- Sales popups work immediately with any other app or theme; no coding required!
- Customize any part of your sales popup with built-in custom CSS and custom JS.
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 4.9/5 | 4.5/5 |
Rating 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups4.9/5 Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup4.5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 223 | 110 |
Reviews 1Click Popups – Email Pop Ups223 Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup110 | ||
| Primary Goal | Email & SMS List Growth | Increase Sales via Social Proof |
Primary Goal 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsEmail & SMS List Growth Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupIncrease Sales via Social Proof | ||
| Popup Types | Email, Discount, Spin Wheel, Announcement | Sales & Add-to-Cart Notifications |
Popup Types 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsEmail, Discount, Spin Wheel, Announcement Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupSales & Add-to-Cart Notifications | ||
| Shop Integration | Direct Lead Capture from Shop Users | None Mentioned |
Shop Integration 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsDirect Lead Capture from Shop Users Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupNone Mentioned | ||
| Customization | Visual Editor for Popup Design | Full Design Control (CSS/JS) |
Customization 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor for Popup Design Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupFull Design Control (CSS/JS) | ||
| Ease of Use | Visual Editor Driven | Plug & Play; No Coding Required |
Ease of Use 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsVisual Editor Driven Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupPlug & Play; No Coding Required | ||
| Value Proposition | Expand subscriber base and marketing reach. | Boost conversion rates with FOMO. |
Value Proposition 1Click Popups – Email Pop UpsExpand subscriber base and marketing reach. Proof Bear ‑ Sales PopupBoost conversion rates with FOMO. | ||
Our Verdict
For merchants primarily focused on building and nurturing an email/SMS marketing list, 1Click Popups is the clear winner. Its features cater specifically to list growth and integration with major email marketing platforms. The Shop integration provides a unique advantage for capturing leads from a large user base.
However, for merchants seeking a quick and easy way to boost sales by leveraging social proof, Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup is the better choice. Its plug-and-play functionality, customization options, and focus on sales notifications make it ideal for creating a sense of urgency and increasing conversion rates. It's particularly suited for stores with high traffic and diverse product ranges, where showcasing recent sales can be highly effective.
Common Questions
Which app is easier to use for a beginner?
Proof Bear likely offers a quicker setup for beginners with its one-click templates and claim of 'no coding required'. While 1Click Popups has a visual editor, the wider array of features may require more initial exploration.
Which app is better for stores that already have a large customer base?
1Click Popups can still be valuable for engaging existing customers and promoting specific offers. However, Proof Bear's social proof features might be more impactful in converting window shoppers into buyers within an established customer base.
Which app is better for a brand new store with low traffic?
Neither app will be particularly effective with very low traffic. 1Click Popups might be slightly better as it builds the email list from scratch, allowing one to start marketing when the number of subscribers is appreciable. Proof Bear will not show any sales if they don't happen.
Does Proof Bear collect emails? If not, can it work together with 1Click Popups?
The description for Proof Bear doesn't explicitly state that it collects email addresses. It focuses on social proof through sales notifications. The two apps could theoretically work together; 1Click Popups could be used for capturing emails, while Proof Bear could provide social proof based on sales generated as a result of the marketing efforts.
Which app is better for capturing abandoned carts?
1Click Popups mentions cart savers as a feature. While Proof Bear aims to increase sales generally, it doesn't explicitly focus on abandoned cart recovery.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store