Best Alternatives to OMNI Memberships & Loyalty CRMfor Shopify (2026)

Shopney allows merchants to create native iOS and Android mobile apps for their store, offering a personalized and faster shopping experience that can drive conversions and increase retention without relying solely on loyalty points. It provides a different approach to customer engagement by focusing on mobile accessibility and app-specific features.

Recurpay offers a robust subscription management system, allowing merchants to unlock recurring revenue through automated subscriptions with features like upfront payments, gift subscriptions, and a customer portal. This provides an alternative to membership programs by focusing on recurring orders rather than loyalty rewards.

Loyoly provides a next-gen rewards and referral program that encourages UGC creation and customer reviews through 40+ available missions. This can be a compelling alternative if OMNI lacks advanced UGC features.

GoodAPI allows merchants to integrate sustainability initiatives like planting trees and removing ocean-bound plastic into their customer engagement strategy, attracting environmentally conscious customers and building brand loyalty through meaningful impact.

Swish offers a feature-rich wishlist solution designed to increase customer engagement and drive conversions. This can be beneficial for stores wanting to provide an intuitive way for customers to track desired products and receive personalized notifications.

Froonze combines loyalty programs with wishlist functionality and an enhanced customer dashboard, all within a unified interface. It also supports native Shopify store credit for cashback rewards.

Wishify focuses on providing a simple and effective wishlist solution to increase sales and traffic. Key benefits include wishlist sharing, customizable buttons, and automated email reminders.

E! Loyalty Program & Rewards provides a comprehensive suite of loyalty features including points, referrals, and VIP tiers. This is a good alternative for merchants looking for a more customizable and gamified loyalty experience.

BLOY focuses on building a loyalty program that drives retention and repeat purchases through points, rewards, VIP tiers, and membership options, complete with 24/7 support. If OMNI's support is lacking or the features aren't driving enough repeat purchases, BLOY offers a potentially stronger alternative.

Love Loyalty Program & Rewards boasts 15+ loyalty program placements and supports paid memberships and POS integrations, offering a wide range of options for engaging customers and selling memberships. This provides a potentially richer feature set.