Best Alternatives to Lantern Loyalty & Rewardsfor Shopify (2026)

While not a direct replacement for a loyalty program, Shopney offers a powerful way to increase customer retention and drive repeat sales through a dedicated mobile app. The push notification feature is a key differentiator, allowing for real-time engagement and personalized offers.

If you're looking to add a subscription model to your business, Recurpay is a strong alternative to simple loyalty programs. It unlocks recurring revenue with 24/7 live human support, automated subscription management, and a customizable customer portal.

Loyoly goes beyond traditional loyalty programs by offering a wide range of missions to encourage user-generated content (UGC) and customer reviews. The customer receives incentives in exchange for creating content.

GoodAPI takes a unique approach to loyalty by focusing on sustainability and social responsibility. It allows merchants to plant trees and remove ocean-bound plastic, appealing to eco-conscious customers. This enhances brand loyalty with positive storytelling.

Swish, while a wishlist app, can indirectly boost loyalty by enhancing customer engagement and providing personalized shopping experiences. Wishlists help customers keep track of desired items, leading to increased conversion rates and customer satisfaction. They also offer a free setup service.

Froonze combines loyalty and wishlist functionalities within a customer account. This provides a centralized location for customers to manage their rewards and saved items. They integrate with Shopify store credit.

Wishify provides fundamental wishlist functionality, helping increase conversion and bringing new traffic to your store. Automated email reminders help recover lost sales.

E! - Loyalty Program & Rewards is a direct competitor, offering similar core features to Lantern Loyalty & Rewards, such as points, referrals, and VIP tiers. The advantage here is the 275 reviews and 24/7 support, potentially offering more confidence and robust support.

BLOY Rewards offers a similar suite of loyalty features to E! - Loyalty program and Rewards. With BLOY Rewards, you will also get access to reward programs and loyalty, reward purchases, VIP tiers and activate referral rewards to grow retention.

Love Loyalty offers a comprehensive loyalty program, with features such as points, rewards, VIP tiers, and referrals. The cart redemption feature allows for a seamless customer experience. They also offer POS support and a membership feature.