Materials Inventory and Settle are both 5-star rated Shopify apps in the Inventory and Inventory Optimization categories, but they cater to distinct needs and target different segments of merchants. Materials Inventory focuses on real-time raw materials and finished goods inventory management, particularly for makers and manufacturers who require bill of materials tracking and profitability analysis. It emphasizes preventing overselling and stockouts by keeping raw materials and finished product inventories in sync. Settle, on the other hand, positions itself as an all-in-one solution for bill pay, procurement, and landed cost workflows, aimed at merchants requiring robust procure-to-pay processes and integration with accounting software like QuickBooks Online, NetSuite, or Finaloop. The critical difference lies in their core functionality. Materials Inventory excels at managing inventory based on raw materials, providing cost and profit tracking, and generating purchase orders. Settle prioritizes streamlining the procurement process, managing vendor payments, and accurately calculating landed costs to improve margin visibility. While Materials Inventory offers custom purchase orders, Settle focuses on comprehensive PO management with approval workflows, indicating a scalability focus suitable for growing teams. Furthermore, Settle directly addresses accounting integration needs, a feature absent from Materials Inventory's description, suggesting that Materials Inventory is best suited for simpler manufacturers or smaller operations that don't require advanced accounting integrations.
49 reviews
18 reviews
Inventory management for makers & manufacturers. Create bills of materials & track profitability
Bill pay, procurement, and landed cost workflows all in one place. Grow fearlessly with Settle.
| Rating | 5/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Materials Inventory5/5 Settle5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 49 | 18 |
Reviews Materials Inventory49 Settle18 | ||
| Target Merchant | Makers & Manufacturers | Businesses needing streamlined procure-to-pay & accounting |
Target Merchant Materials InventoryMakers & Manufacturers SettleBusinesses needing streamlined procure-to-pay & accounting | ||
| Core Functionality | Raw Material & Product Inventory Management | Bill Pay, Procurement, & Landed Cost Management |
Core Functionality Materials InventoryRaw Material & Product Inventory Management SettleBill Pay, Procurement, & Landed Cost Management | ||
| Key Feature: Purchase Orders | Custom Purchase Orders | PO Management with Approval Workflows |
Key Feature: Purchase Orders Materials InventoryCustom Purchase Orders SettlePO Management with Approval Workflows | ||
| Key Feature: Accounting | Not Mentioned | Integrates with QBO, NetSuite, Finaloop |
Key Feature: Accounting Materials InventoryNot Mentioned SettleIntegrates with QBO, NetSuite, Finaloop | ||
| Value Proposition | Prevent overselling, track profitability | Streamline procurement, improve margin visibility |
Value Proposition Materials InventoryPrevent overselling, track profitability SettleStreamline procurement, improve margin visibility | ||
| Ease of Use Focus | Intuitive & easy to use | Streamlined flow |
Ease of Use Focus Materials InventoryIntuitive & easy to use SettleStreamlined flow | ||
For makers and manufacturers who need to meticulously track raw materials, manage bills of materials, and calculate product profitability with real-time inventory updates, Materials Inventory is likely the better choice. Its simplicity and focus on the inventory-to-production process makes it ideal for smaller operations or those who prioritize ease of use above all else. It also helps to create custom purchase orders.
On the other hand, if a business needs a comprehensive solution for managing the entire procurement process, including purchase orders, approval workflows, vendor payments, and integration with accounting software to accurately reflect landed costs, Settle provides a more robust and scalable platform. For growing businesses that require more sophisticated procurement management and accounting system integration, Settle is the superior option.
Materials Inventory, due to its focus on raw materials tracking and ease of use, is generally better for small craft businesses that make products from components.
Settle integrates with QuickBooks Online, NetSuite, and Finaloop. Materials Inventory does not explicitly mention accounting integrations.
Materials Inventory tracks raw material costs and product profitability, which can inform pricing decisions. Settle helps with accurate pricing by syncing landed costs, ensuring all expenses are factored in.
Yes, both apps aim to prevent overselling. Materials Inventory updates inventory in real-time. Settle helps prevent stockouts by optimizing the procure-to-pay process.
Materials Inventory is highlighted as 'intuitive & easy to use' so will likely be easier to set up, where Settle may require more setup and configuration due to its integration with other systems and more complex features.
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store