Afterpay On‑Site Messaging vs TryOnify: Try Before You Buyfor Shopify (2026)
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging and TryOnify: Try Before You Buy are both Shopify apps in the Payments category, but cater to different merchant needs and target distinct consumer behaviors. Afterpay focuses on leveraging the established brand recognition of Afterpay to drive conversions by highlighting the buy-now-pay-later option directly on product and cart pages, targeting Millennial and Gen Z shoppers. Its strength lies in visual customization and brand alignment of messaging. TryOnify, on the other hand, introduces a 'Try Now, Pay Later' model, differentiating itself from standard BNPL solutions. It aims to reduce cart abandonment by offering a free trial period before payment, acquiring customers sustainably. While both apps address payment friction, Afterpay assumes the customer is already familiar and comfortable with BNPL, whereas TryOnify seeks to overcome initial hesitation by providing a risk-free trial. The choice depends on whether a merchant wants to capitalize on existing BNPL familiarity or introduce a new, trial-based payment model.
At a Glance
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging
46 reviews
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy
4 reviews
Detailed Overview
Afterpay On‑Site Messaging
Convert more Next Gen shoppers with Afterpay’s On-Site Messaging App
Key Features
- Add messaging easily to product and cart pages with a visual editor
- Adjust mobile view, add footer icons, and personalize theme to match your brand
- Set minimum/maximum order limit messaging to match your account
TryOnify: Try Before You Buy
Provide customers with a free trial shopping experience in minutes.
Key Features
- Quick & easy setup
- No usage-based tax that eats into your profits
- Automatic payment collection when the trial ends
- Automatic credit card authorizations to ensure payment on time
- Reauthorize credit cards for longer trial periods
Feature Comparison
| Rating | 2.9/5 | 5/5 |
Rating Afterpay On‑Site Messaging2.9/5 TryOnify: Try Before You Buy5/5 | ||
| Reviews | 46 | 4 |
Reviews Afterpay On‑Site Messaging46 TryOnify: Try Before You Buy4 | ||
| Payment Model | Buy Now, Pay Later Messaging | Try Now, Pay Later |
Payment Model Afterpay On‑Site MessagingBuy Now, Pay Later Messaging TryOnify: Try Before You BuyTry Now, Pay Later | ||
| Target Audience | Millennials & Gen Z (BNPL Users) | Customers hesitant about initial purchase |
Target Audience Afterpay On‑Site MessagingMillennials & Gen Z (BNPL Users) TryOnify: Try Before You BuyCustomers hesitant about initial purchase | ||
| Core Benefit | Increased conversion through BNPL awareness | Reduced cart abandonment with free trials |
Core Benefit Afterpay On‑Site MessagingIncreased conversion through BNPL awareness TryOnify: Try Before You BuyReduced cart abandonment with free trials | ||
| Customization | Visual editor for on-site messaging | Focus on backend automation of trials & payments |
Customization Afterpay On‑Site MessagingVisual editor for on-site messaging TryOnify: Try Before You BuyFocus on backend automation of trials & payments | ||
| Value Proposition | Leverages established BNPL brand | Attracts customers with risk-free experience |
Value Proposition Afterpay On‑Site MessagingLeverages established BNPL brand TryOnify: Try Before You BuyAttracts customers with risk-free experience | ||
Our Verdict
If a merchant already sees significant adoption of Afterpay or wants to target younger demographics familiar with BNPL, Afterpay On-Site Messaging is the more suitable choice. The app allows for customization and reinforcement of the payment option on key pages. However, the lower rating and higher review count should prompt a closer look at recent reviews to understand potential pain points.
For merchants struggling with high cart abandonment rates and wanting to offer a more innovative and less financially-committing alternative, TryOnify is a compelling option. While the number of reviews is small, the perfect rating suggests a positive initial user experience. TryOnify's 'Try Now, Pay Later' model can be particularly effective for products where customers hesitate due to uncertainty or perceived risk.
Common Questions
Which app better caters to impulse buyers?
Afterpay On-Site Messaging likely caters better to impulse buyers already comfortable with BNPL. It reinforces the 'buy now' aspect with convenient payment options.
Which app is easier to set up?
TryOnify emphasizes 'Quick & easy setup', while Afterpay focuses on visual editing. So, TryOnify probably would be faster to set up, though Afterpay gives more control over look & feel. But without hands-on testing, this is not certain.
Which app has more brand recognition?
Afterpay, as a well-established BNPL provider, has significantly more brand recognition than the new TryOnify.
Does Afterpay On-Site Messaging affect the actual payment process?
No, Afterpay On-Site Messaging only promotes the availability of Afterpay. It doesn't handle the payment processing itself, but it influences how customers perceive the checkout options.
Which app is more aligned with 'ethical' consumerism?
TryOnify explicitly positions itself as a non-predatory alternative to BNPL, aligning with 'ethical' consumerism. Afterpay, while convenient, can contribute to debt accumulation if not used responsibly.
Get More From Your Shopify Store
Run audits for SEO, CRO, PageSpeed, and AI visibility. Get a clear report and actionable fixes.
Try Fix My Store